Guerriero Gelato & Cakes

This place has the best ice cream and the people there are so nice and some of them are generous with the amount of ice cream you want, been there since I was 7 and love it.

I love Guerriero everyone that lives in Caldwell has been there. It's impossible to walk in without knowing someone!! Fan favorite all the way. Plus, anyone that is in to Geocaching there is a cache right in the parking lot. Kid-friendliness: Definitely a place meant for kids (and parents too)!

The gelato is my favorite. There’s new specials every few weeks. The staff always go above and beyond to make it a friendly and welcoming experience. The manager was very knowledgeable about the ingredients and flavors of each item. Will definitely be coming back very soon!!

I always love coming back to this establishment they have so many new varieties to try and there all fabulous I love the new ricotta cranberry cheesecake gelato they have a wonderful polite staff good customer service there always. Coming up with new ideas and flavors they are friendly family orientated and overall the best gelato around go give them a try you won't be disappointed

Great ice cream! Definitely recommend the Mint Oreo!

One of the BEST ice cream shops around the area! Staff is always friendly and the gelato is the best in north jersey for a reason, i would come back again!

I’ve heard employees don’t get their personal tips and are split amongst managers. THIS IS UNFAIR TO ALL THE EMPLOYEES!!! And they are also working under poor working conditions and are not supervised to wear gloves while serving us which is very UNSANITARY!!! AND IVE ALSO SEEN BUGS ON THE ICE CREAM

Best gelato ever tasted not from around the area so it was nice finding this shop