Gordons Milkshake Bar

Me alone with my husband decided to go get a milkshake 03/03/2024 around 5pm. The way we was greeted was so unexceptionable and uncalled for. The cashier greeted us with “CAN YOU CLOSE MY DOOR , I NEED TO KEEP MY MACHINES COLD !” As if I was trying to hold the door open just because. My husband alone with someone else was coming in behind me. Puzzled and confused on how me opening the door to come in is causing your machines (that Im sure runs all day and all night ) to defrost , I along with my husband just left out. If this is how you greet someone who’s supporting the establishment you work I would rather not spend my money here.

This place has gone so downhill. It’s so sad to see because their milkshakes are really good. Third time I’ve been there in six weeks and the ice cream machine is broken. Starting to sound like McDonald’s. You also can’t call them or find any updates on any social media.

Didn’t taste very good

While these shakes look delicious they taste terrible. Unfortunately you can taste the poor quality of ingredients used and our entire family had stomach issues after drinking these. I would not recommend.

Ice cream is super good but they technically close 20 mins early since they shut everything down early

Went on a Saturday night and there were 6 people waiting before us and took over 30 minutes to get our 2 shakes. When we finally got our shakes they were so flavorless. I got the midnight cookies and cream and my husband got the signature cookies and cream and could not even tell the difference between them. Tastes like they use unflavored ice cream and just add cookies to it. The atmosphere was really dark, staff did not even acknowledge anyone coming in or even say hi once getting to the counter and it was silent in there with no music or anything.

I have no clue what I order from here, but I absolutely adore this place. While the service could use a bit of improvement, the overall vibe is just fantastic. Just a heads up, the location is quite small, so expect to take your order to go. Also, it can get quite busy, so a little patience goes a long way. Parking is a bit limited too, so if possible, consider walking or biking to the location. One more thing to note: unfortunately, the residents living above this place can be quite unpleasant. During my visit, someone even threw water down from their apartment onto patrons waiting to enter the restaurant, which was completely uncalled for.