Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mass Ave.

Great service, nice atmosphere. Pizza is chewy and greasy (i'd score it a 5.8). Great for drunk 2 am pizza.

Fun themed pizzeria in the heart of Mass. Ave. Concerns I had were the overall cleanliness of the tables during my visit. Many were dirty, and nobody seemed to be concerned with cleaning them. The food was alright.

1/2 slices in Mondays. Pizza is good.

Love the pizza and love the bourbon bar in the back. Awesome place on Mass Ave

Fast service and delicious food! My must-have when visiting Indy!

Went in it was freezing inside. It was 10 degrees outside at 10 pm. It was my first time dining here so I didn’t know where I should have ordered and they didn’t have signs as to where I should go.Staff was not trying to be helpful at all. Got the pizza really fast apparently pies had just came out. Sat down to eat my slice and I noticed a long hair in my food. My boyfriend took it back and got different slice , I inspected it and I’ll be damn another hair. They still left the pies out and were selling them out of the display, did not throw them away. All the men working had no gloves and no hair nets for head or beards. They did give my bf half of his money back, but not one hair but TWO! Unacceptable.

Unfortunately the pizza was mediocre & service was poor, got a Goodfella Pizza & buffalo cheese bread for $52.