Goodfellas Pizzeria - Kirkwood

I used to have an obsession with Goodfellas. I would go there multiple times a week, and every single time the staff was very kind and patient! They keep very busy too!

Lovely gem of a find. Will be back

We got one xlarge pizza & breadsticks for 5 people, and there was a lot left over. It was really good & super fresh, hot out of the oven when we picked it up. The whole family really enjoyed it!

Great New York style pizza. As a New Yorker, I grew up on pizza by the slice. The atmosphere is great. Great service, and more importantly, the food is great. Great variety of pies as well.

Great pizza

If you want a New York slice this is it. There's plenty of pizza around but this place is all about New York style. The pizza is always consistent and good. The staff is beyond excellent. Highly recommended.

Was looking forward to New York style pizza. Guess you only get that if you order by the slice. Would have been helpful to know that beforehand. Pizza could do without the oregano, as could the breadsticks…there are other better flavors to use. Pizza was ok and the breadsticks were pretty decent, just leave out the oregano. Breadsticks are pretty decent size too, you could manage with one per person unless you’re starving! Cheese sauce and garlic butter were very tasty! Staff was friendly, place was super small though, just a few tables. Remember, if you want NY style, order by the slice!! Might go back to try again!

Decent slice of New York Pizza. Their bradsticks are not quite as good as the pizza. Good crust, decent toppings. The lunch special is a good deal - a slice, a side (breadstick or salad) a drink for $9.

Best slice in Bloomington huge slices. Hot and fresh. Love the vibe this place has.

Amazing place to go grab a slice after a night out at the bars. All my friends and I LOVE the lunch special too! The slice is so big it’s bigger than my face. Kid-friendliness: All ages were there and welcomed with open arms.