Goodfellas Pizzeria - Broad Ripple

Those guys are absolutely awesome. Definitely great people and great service. Pizza was delicious as always

Quick, and large portions.

Only three slices of pizza available at 5:30 on a Friday and they looked like they had been there for hours. And they were banana peppers and stuff. No cheese or pepperoni at all and none in the oven. Workers did not care. The place has gone downhill. No parking anymore. Won’t be back.

Pizza is hands down best pizza in town and the slices and prices are on point. Customer service is always good

One of the better if not best New York style pizza spots your gonna find in the Indianapolis area

I really enjoy Goodfellas Pizzeria easily my favorite in Indianapolis and probably the whole of Indiana. I drive about an hour and a half to come to Goodfellas. The only knock on this location is there is not a lot of seating. Just a bar with a few stools. For this reason I usually go to the Mass Ave location since I tend to take a large group. I would rather come to this location since the Mass Ave location does not care about you if you are ordering a pie for dine in.

Combination of thin crust on Veggie pizza was great . And its all good for kosher/ halal /vegetarian dietary choices people!!