Sadly, the ice cream here is mediocre. Quality is decent but not great, and most of the flavors are strange. The staff is awesome and the setting is clean and inviting, but the product doesn't live up to the hype.
Ever changing hours with this place. Love their ice cream but you’ll need luck catching them open with consistent, normal business hours. 2/8/23 Update: Closed during mid-day until 4 PM now ♀️ Make sure you check hours before driving over. No ice cream for us today. We will drive over to another option close-by instead. Update: Unfortunately back in October they changed their hours on Google maps indicating they were currently closed all day and opening at 6PM but they forgot it change them back until the end of January! We’ve missed a lot of ice cream and expect they’ve missed a lot of sales. Glad to know they’re open during the day again. Update: New hours fall of 2021- winter 2022 hours are so disappointing. ONLY open after dark at 6 PM....ice cream at night only. I’m only in the downtown area during the day. Prepare to be addicted to Salted Oreo...seriously delicious. Finding parking out on the streets surrounding the shop is typically a challenge though.
Amazing!!!! I LOVE the salted oreo flavor. Would highly recommend. It's also a very nice shop and the service is great.
Not a whole lot of options but we got a flight of ice cream and none of the flavors disappointed. Highly recommend the gingerbread pear ice cream it was one of the best flavors I’ve ever had.
Claire, at Golden Cow, did a great job addressing the request of adding sprinkles to the Salted Oreo! Not only did she add sprinkles, but she made sure the entire cup was covered in the sprinkley sensation. She also had a great smile and customer service! Well done.
I went over there because I saw on line the place has “hot fudge”, so I asked for it and then I had the surprise that for that ice cream store HOT FUDGE Means Cheap hersheys chocolate syrup. Cow creamery: there’s a HUGE difference between cold Hersheys Choc. Syrup and HOT FUDGE, so please don’t advertise things that you don’t have, so disappointed.
Went off the high reviews and were disappointed. The ice cream was just ehhh…not the worst but not a 5 star in flavor or menu selection. We had someone who was needing dairy free and because of an earlier review saw they also offered dairy free, however they only had one flavor and it was a sorbet. So 2 star for flavor, 1 star for vegan options, 1 star for variety on menu = 1 star review