Glass Nickel Pizza Co. - Madison West

This is my favorite place for pizza when I'm in the Madison area.

I don't know what has happened to this place over the last few months, but I would not recommend ordering from here. First off, delivery times have gone WAY up. As for our last four pizzas/orders, the crust has been soggy and the cheese isn't even warm upon delivery. Isn't it best practice to use a warming/insulated transport bag? Also, they should note that if you order anything extra for your pasta dishes, those ingredients will be RAW. Thank you SO much for the raw onion, garlic, and mushrooms for the spaghetti. This place gets a long-awaited time out for us. Save your wasted money and choose a better restuarant.

Better than Ian's but they do not give accurate wait times, I don't care if things are going to take a while just please provide an accurate time estimate. Last time it was 40 minutes late for a pickup.

Arguably one of the best pizza joints in the city. Always delicious and a great choice of specialties. The poppers are fantastic!

Our go to spot for pizza! Everything else on the menu is delicious as well. Subs, salads, chicken strips, everything!

All 3 pizzas were great, but the fetaliscious was the best!