Four & Twenty Blackbirds

In Brooklyn’s realm, where pies entwine, Four and Twenty Blackbirds, a sweet shrine. On Pie Day’s eve, with stars aligned, I entered in, a feast designed. With matcha custard, a vibrant hue, And malted pecan, a flavor true. Malted chocolate, a velvety surprise, Each slice a tale beneath the skies. Salted honey, a golden flow, And lavender honey, a scent to know. But amongst them all, a nod to lore, The blackbirds baked, forevermore. Yet fear not, for no birds were harmed, Just flavors crafted, finely charmed. At Four and Twenty, tales take flight, In every pie, a song of delight. So come and taste this culinary art, At Four and Twenty, where dreams impart. With blackbirds baked and flavors high, A slice of heaven, ‘neath Brooklyn’s sky.

I've been here twice, had a slice of the salted caramel apple as well as the pumpkin and WOW, both were incredible. I'm not normally the biggest fan of pumpkin, but this one was just out of this world, thick and rich and the perfect ratio of crust to filling. The bakery itself is cute and charming, and the staff were kind and welcoming. I highly recommend!

Always a solid pie, their menu is often seasonal with a few staples. Perfect crust (which they are known for). Their matcha, honey lavender, and apple pie are my favorite. Try their ice cream or whip cream. All worth the price.

Cute place. I only stopped in for an espresso drink so can’t speak for anything else but it was so bitter and gross I had to throw it out after the first sip. Might have just been an off day?

I love the pies here. Try your whatever your favorite filling is and you most likely won’t regret it.

Have always loved this place. Terrible, rude service on a Monday morning. I was having trouble accessing my credit card to pay because of limited phone service (I ended up being able to pay), the server was extremely rude to me. I also ordered a cold brew, requesting a splash of milk. It turned out to be a cup of cold milk with a splash of cold brew. I asked the server to give me more cold brew, and they begrudingly poured some of my drink out slightly to barely put cold brew in there, and return to me a milky coffee. This server acted like I was inconveniencing them when I was a paying customer. Kindness goes a long way. Their attitude was extremely unnecessary.

Had an absolute blast here!!! Fantastic service, great music. Tried the lemon - highly recommended. The brown butter apple - also yum. Matcha pie - first miss. Tasted like dirt. I'd definitely visit again. Great indoor seating atmosphere as well.

we drove out of our way to come here and have been long time customers since you have opened. the girl working the counter 1/28 around 5 pm is ruining your brand. she was soo rude and had no customer service skills whatsoever. we watched her behavior with multiple customers aside from our experience and left with such a bad taste in our mouth. sorry to the dude sharing the tip pool with her

Have been coming here for 10+ years now. The pies and service are consistently excellent no matter who is behind the counter. Favorite pies are the chocolate chess, lemon chess, and all of the summer fruit pies.