Fogarty's Menu

4.5
(3,650+ Reviews)
  • Appetizers

    • Conch Fritters

      Key West classic with Bahamian conch & island spices, served with Cocktail Sauce for dipping.
      $13.00
    • Mahi Mahi Bites

      Mahi strips battered and fried golden brown, served with Tartar Sauce.
      $15.00
    • Peppered Ahi Tuna

      Rare Ahi tuna with fresh cracked black peppercorns, crispy rice noodle garnish, Spicy Red Chili Soy Sauce, & wasabi.
      $17.00
    • Chilled Peel & Eat Shrimp

      Peel, eat, and enjoy. ½ pound of seasoned shrimp with tangy Cocktail Sauce & lemon.
      $16.00
    • Bruschetta

      Buttery baguette with chopped Roma tomatoes, garlic, basil, oregano, olive oil, fresh mozzarella, & Sweet Balsamic Glaze.
      $12.00
    • Quesadilla

      Grilled flour tortillas with melted cheese, grilled onions, green peppers, & jalapenos. Served with salsa & sour cream on the side.
      $12.00
    • Buffalo Chicken Tenders

      Boneless chicken strips tossed in homemade buffalo sauce and served with celery & blue cheese.
      $15.00
    • Tex-Mex Rolls

      Grilled chicken, roasted corn, black beans, cilantro, peppers, onions, jalapenos, and mixed cheeses in a golden brown egg roll, served with sour cream and salsa.
      $15.00
  • Salads

    • Santa Fe Chicken Salad

      Diced chicken, romaine hearts, roasted corn, black beans, tomatoes, cheddar & jack cheeses, tortilla strips, & our Lime Cilantro Dressing.
      $18.00
    • Ahi Salad

      Sesame-crusted Yellowfin tuna cooked rare, diced tomatoes & cucumbers, mixed greens, & our Balsamic Vinaigrette.
      $19.00
    • Chinese Chicken Salad

      Crispy chicken tossed in Sesame Sauce, wontons, rice sticks, almonds, green onions, Mandarin oranges, & a blend of lettuces tossed in Asian Vinaigrette.
      $17.00
    • Caesar Salad

      Romaine hearts, parmesan, croutons, & Romano cheese.
      $11.00
    • Cobb Salad

      Romaine hearts, crispy bacon crumbles, hard cooked eggs, diced tomatoes, grilled chicken breast, crumbled blue cheese, & house Balsamic vinaigrette.
      $18.00
  • Sandwiches

    • Shrimp Po Boy

      A heapin’ bunch of fried shrimp with lettuce, tomato, & Caper Remoulade.
      $17.00
    • Fogarty’s Fish Sandwich

      Fried golden brown filet with lettuce, tomato, & Tartar Sauce.
      $17.00
    • Blackened Shrimp Wrap

      Spicy shrimp wrapped in a spinach tortilla with crumbled bacon, romaine lettuce, diced tomatoes, parmesan cheese, & tangy Caesar Dressing.
      $17.00
    • Shrimp And Bacon Sandwich

      Grilled shrimp, smoked bacon, swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, and our Tomato Basil Dressing on toasted wheat.
      $17.00
    • Fogarty’s Burger

      Fresh 12 oz hand-pattied ground beef grilled to perfection, with lettuce, tomato, & grilled onions.
      $15.00
    • Dolphin Sandwich

      Grilled Mahi Mahi seasoned with lemon & herbs. Topped with grilled onions, lettuce, & tomato.
      $17.00
    • BBQ Bacon Burger

      12 oz. burger topped with BBQ Sauce, BBQ Ranch, cheddar cheese, bacon, lettuce, and fried onion.
      $17.00
    • Chicken Cheesesteak

      Grilled chicken, bell peppers, and onions topped with provolone cheese, spicy mayo, lettuce, & tomato.
      $16.00
  • Entrees

    • Fresh Catch

      Locally caught fresh fish served with rice and vegetables. Blackened with Cajun spices or sautéed with Key Lime Butter.
      $28.00
    • Pecan Catch

      Fresh filet of locally caught fish crusted with pecans and honey, deglazed with Chardonnay and served with Lemon Cream Sauce, rice, & vegetables.
      $29.00
    • Blackened Fish Tacos

      Mahi Mahi in warm flour tortillas with creamy lime-cilantro sauce, mixed cheese, and sweet onion citrus slaw, served with rice & black beans.
      $24.00
    • Smokey Joe’s Ribs

      Tender Baby Back pork ribs, Crazy Lady BBQ Sauce, French Fries, & cole slaw.
    • Three Cheese Pasta

      Parmesan, mozzarella, & ricotta cheeses with penne pasta and garlic in a Creamy Marinara Sauce topped with fresh basil.
      $21.00
    • Broccolini

      Grilled chicken, penne pasta, & fresh broccoli in a Creamy Parmesan Sauce.
      $23.00
    • Crusted Chicken Romano

      Parmesan and Romano crusted chicken breast with Creamy Garlic Marinara over penne pasta.
      $24.00
    • Cuban Pork Bowl

      Mojo-marinated and slow roasted pork, onions, rice, black beans, and fried sweet plantains.
      $19.00
    • Key Lime Shrimp

      Sautéed shrimp over Key Lime Cilantro Sauce, served with rice & vegetables.
      $26.00
    • Caribbean Steak

      Grilled, marinated steak with fried sweet plantains, black beans, and rice.
      $28.00
  • Sides

    • French Fries

      $7.00
    • Black Beans

      $6.00
    • Rice

      $6.00
    • Cole Slaw

      $4.00
    • Broccoli

      $7.00
  • Desserts

    • Key Lime Pie

      $6.00

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

22&Co
22&Co
4.6
(137 Reviews)
Bar
Mangoes Restaurant
Mangoes Restaurant
4.2
(1,924 Reviews)
Caribbean, Bar, Brunch
The Birdcage Cabaret
The Birdcage Cabaret
4.4
(60 Reviews)
Cabaret club, Bar, Night club
Aquabelle
Aquabelle
Restaurant
The Back Bar
The Back Bar
4.5
(17 Reviews)
Bar
Aqua Bar and Nightclub
Aqua Bar and Nightclub
4.3
(492 Reviews)
Night club, Bar
Pinchers
Pinchers
4.2
(2,985 Reviews)
Seafood, Restaurant
Key West Shave Ice & Frozen Tap
Key West Shave Ice & Frozen Tap
4.9
(94 Reviews)
Restaurant
Smoothie Bay
Smoothie Bay
3.6
(54 Reviews)
Restaurant

+1 305-294-7525

227 Duval St, Key West, FL 33040


© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms