Fish Tales Market and Eatery

By far the best seared ahi yellowfin tuna I have ever eaten!!! Definitely try it!

The fish and calamari were so fresh and delicious. Brian our Bartender and server was very Knowledgeable and friendly Definitely recommend and will be back!!

My husband and I stopped here for a meal while on vacation. I ordered the blackened mahi mahi platter with new potatoes, all of which were absolutely delicious. My husband got the blackened cobia with French fries and the taste I had of his was equally yummy. I followed with my first piece of key lime pie ever. I loved the frozen nature of this pie and feel like it was a great introduction!

We’ve been in Marathon for 4 days and are here our last night. Wish we came here first because I think we would have not gone anywhere else the rest of the week. This is hands down the best food we’ve had in the Keys and the key lime pie is our top pick as well!

Genuinely one of my favorite meals I’ve had during my visit to the keys. The pretzel was amazing and the key lime pie was the best I’ve ever had. Service was amazing. Highly suggest!!

Known for the key lime pie. It's definitely a local establishment. We seated outside and I'm my opinion that was a mistake. I had to go inside multiple times to get service. Trust me I'm not a demanding individual. I get a small establishment. Overall food was good . The service gal was overwhelmed. My advice is to sit inside for better service. Only reason we didn't sit inside is because it smelled like fish. Make no mistake the key lime pie was the best in marathon.

My recent visit to Fish Market with friends prompted me to share our experience, particularly for those of us who are from ethnic minority backgrounds. Although the cuisine at Fish Market met our expectations in terms of quality, our dining experience was marred by the distinct feeling of being treated differently than other guests. It’s challenging to label these interactions as outright racism, yet the disparate attitude and service we encountered were palpable and left us feeling unwelcome. This sentiment was echoed by several of my friends, confirming that our experience was not an isolated incident. I wish to clarify that this review is not an indictment of Fish Market but rather an expression of our experience. For those sensitive to the nuances of social treatment, this might be a factor to consider when choosing a dining location.

Food just ok.