Firehouse Grill

The service was great. Food was poor. Ordered burger (no temp asked) and it was very very rare. Sent it back asking for med well, and the center was still very pink and raw looking. Again, service was good. The food was inconsistent. Some fries seasoned, some not.

If I lived in Evanston, I’d be here every week. The charm of the restored firehouse is clear both outside and inside, and the happy sounds of people eating, drinking, and having fun greeted us as soon as we entered. The 14 beers on tap had a wide variety, including my faves — stouts, hazy IPA, and Belgian white. I got Son of Juice, the Maplewood hazy. Yum. There’s also wine and a full bar. My friend ordered a cheeseburger and I got the Barbecue Chicken Pizza; both were great! The pizza is deep dish but rectangular in shape, served on a 10x14 baking sheet (Detroit Style). I had lots left to take with me, and I ate it on the road the next day. We splurged on a Cookie Skillet for dessert — wow. So good. The outside patio, strung with white lights, looks like a really funplace to eat and drink when it’s warm. All in all, we loved Firehouse! Parking: Be aware that the lot on the same side of the street to the south is not owned by Firehouse. You can park there, but it’s a pay lot. We got there on the earlier side and found free on-street parking nearby. Wheelchair accessibility: There’s a single wheelchair parking place on the south side of the building. The entrance, seating, and restroom are all accessible.

Great visit. Hope to visit soon.

The burgers were hearty and delicious. Servers were friendly but I had an issue when we ordered the lava cake. This is a thorn in my side is. the menu advertises a chocolate “lava cake” and this is definitely not a lava cake. It doesn’t have any ooey gooey inside. When the server came to ask how the lava cake was, we were honest and said it wasn’t that good. She made a face and said she agreed. A warning would have been nice.

This place has gone down the fire pole. Just had the most mediocre lunch there. The pizza used to be really good. The past two times we’ve gone, each was a step down. They used to use pulled chicken now it’s these dry overcooked little tiny chunks. The veggie pizza used to be loaded with veggies and had artichokes and more sauce and man it was good. Now it’s just same old stuff like an old tired Pizza Hut supreme pizza. Maybe the clientele likes that I have no idea. But it’s no longer worth the calories. On top of the toppings issue the music was just all kinds of loud generic jock rock like what you’d see on a “90s party rock CD they sell at a gas station off the turnpike. Both my wife and I were anxious to leave bummed because we lived off this pizza during the pandemic.

The Firehouse grill has an air of casual sophistication. The patrons varied from families to couple on dates. The food was really good we had jambalaya and vegie quesadilla with fries. The drink was tastey but a little small for 12. We had a regular coffee with one refill for 8. I thought 4 bucks for a refill out of line. The service was ok. Ill be back.

Great atmosphere. Awesome outdoor patio -- even when it's cold (nice heaters). Staff is super friendly and attentive, especially CiCi. Adorable! Firehouse also has a really nice party room. Booked for several events in the past and everyone had a great time. Menu has something for everyone and the food is delish. Definitely my go to when I don't feel like cooking OR I just want to sit at the bar and have a cold beer (great selection) or a glass of wine (good options). Bar staff is knowledgeable, friendly, and attentive.