Extreme Pizza Mill Valley

I have eaten ALOT of pizza in my life and this place was by far the worst. Went in for a slice, which costed $6 for a rather small slice of pizza, and to my amazement there didn’t seem to be a single fresh slice pie. People inside were nice which is the only positive thing you could say. Pizza must have been a day old at least. Poor quality ingredients obviously, dough tasted worse than cardboard, sauce was closer to ketchup than tomato sauce, and the cheese was rather bad. I’d go to Dominos before I’d eat a pizza from here.

Mediocre pizza and quite bad service. They’ve botch several of my orders over time. And they don’t follow their own operating hours. You can order a pizza online, get an estimated pick up time, and show up to find it closed. Rocco’s is much more reliable.

hung up on me when I tried to order, TWICE. also Google says that they're open for delivery, but apparently you have to pickup.

Pizza is great when they actually are open. Hours on the website and google maps are wrong. They close early all of the time. Twice now we’ve placed an online order just to find out they closed early.

This place smells dirty and the staff aren't very friendly

Really nice owners who kept the dining room open for us and food was excellent

Nobody likes cold food