We love Athena Gyro, and have been wanting to try this bagel shop for months hoping the food would be equally amazing. We visited last Sunday and although it was busy & hectic, it was worth the wait and service was attentive and polite. The interior is small and they are serving a large volume of customers, so yes it’s confusing if people are waiting to order but we had no issue being served. We had two bacon egg and cheese on an everything egg bagel and my son had a muffin and a croissant (neither of which I tasted) but both looked delicious. The bagel sandwiches were divine and quite filling and generous with the bacon. The bagels themselves were chewy and it was a really good sandwich. Perhaps next time I will order ahead, but I would like to try their bagels on their own. It’s been hard to find a good chewy bagel since moving to Dutchess a few years ago. These were pretty close to hitting the mark and I can see why they were packed on a Sunday morning.
Best bagel I have ever eaten
Great service, great food!