The ice cream here is so overrated. The variety of flavors is basic with the occasional flavor being maybe slightly interesting. The texture is mid and I felt like it was kind of warm for ice cream. The prices aren’t bad, especially for the neighborhood, and the vibe is cool but the service is pretty bad. There was only one girl working and she didn’t seem thrilled about being there…
I had the cookie monster flavor. I have to say though, after finishing our respective ice cream cups, my friend and I both immediately fell asleep. I swear the ice cream had some drowsy/antihistamine effects going on
Great value and very good ice cream and service
Good ice cream, definitely recommend.
Its an amazing ice cream place, lots of option, great price and taste delish! I suggest the watermelon sorbet.. owh so good, yumm
Such a wonderful family-owned ice cream shop! Our favorite place in UES. Amazing ice cream and coffee. Friendly owners and staff. Great location next to East River :D
Good ice cream, great value. The guys behind the counter are really nice at this ice cream shop that's been in its current location for about 4 years or so according to one of the guys there. A $6 medium cup can get you three flavors. I chose cookie monster, pistachio, and cupcake. Each flavor was really good. I think the Pistachio was the best of the three. I noticed they also have soft serve, so I'll have to give that a go and compare it to Carvel in my mind. Open late, quick to serve, and short lines. I'll be back.
This place only has a multitude of 5 star reviews because if you leave one you get a free topping. It is certainly not worthy of any stars. The staff is extremely rude. When someone mentions “creamy ice cream” in a review they must mean melted ice cream. Both the soft serve and hard ice cream are always liquid. The taste isn’t great either. To top it off, they got rid of their punch cards and raised prices. It only does well because it’s the only ice cream spot on York in the area. You’re WAY better off walking one avenue up to Sedutto which is actual good ice cream and friendly staff.