Crumbl - Reynoldsburg

My kids and I ; this is our second time trying Crumbl. First time in the store. We loved this weeks cookies. Our least favorite was s’mores. The Golden Oreo cookie was a house favorite. Please keep in mind these cookies are huge and very sweet. I cut each cookie into 4 so we all have a decent size piece to try. I ordered online and picked up in store. I was not greeted upon entry but after I checked in on the app I was greeted and watched my order get packed up.

Forgive me. Beautiful store. Smelled delightful. Ordering experience was easy, staff was friendly and prompt. I just did not care for any of these cookies at all. And they are giant and beautifully made. And I was looking forward to a treat after a yucky day, but unfortunately I just did not like any of these cookies. Not enough salt is the only thing I could figure. They are made with butter eggs, flour, sugar...all the good stuff, but they tasted sweet and bland. 48 hours later. 4 bites out of 2 of the 4 cookies and I am only feeling bad about throwing them out because of wasted money, ingredients, and resources. People would be thrilled with these. Sadly I was not one of them. And I like other cookie places and don't use them often. Crumbl will not be among my future choices.

Everytime we go they are always top tier everything is always good.

Highly recommend! They never disappoint! My daughter’s first cookie was from here and shes addicted just as much as I am lol! We usually go through the app to place our orders, and from experience the warmth of my cookie even sat (due to my timing) it was still warm in its box when I picked it up! When we did go in the store and ordered our cookies they were quick and sufficient! The taste of any cookie from them is fresh and can tell it was made with love. I love Crumbl I haven’t had a bad experience yet with them!

Amazing