Crotty's Cheesesteaks Menu

$$Cheesesteak

8 Eastchester Rd, New Rochelle, NY 10801

Order Online

Suggest Edit

Cheesesteak Sandwich EXTREME Cheesesteak Sandwiches Extras Dessert Beverages Specials Catering Kids

Cheesesteak Sandwich
- The New Yorker
  Caramelized onions, grilled tomatoes, cheddar cheese
  $16.25
- The Irishman
  Crispy bacon, caramelized onions, mushrooms, brown gravy, cheddar cheese
  $16.25
- The French Dip
  Provolone cheese, side of warm au jus for dipping
  $16.25
- The Sicilian
  Broccoli rabe, Italian hot peppers, grilled tomatoes, basil, provolone cheese
  $16.25
- The Club
  lettuce, tomato, mayo, American cheese, crispy bacon
  $16.25
- The Traditional
  Whiz, Caramelized Onions
  $14.95
- The Steakhouse Cheesesteak
  Gorgonzola Cheese, Caramelized Onions & Side of warm Au Jus for dipping
  $16.25
- Caesar Wrap Cheesesteak
  Served on a Bed of Fresh Romaine, Imported Shredded Parmesan Cheese, Topped with Crotty’s Creamy Caesar Dressing. *Can be served cold
  $16.25
- Caprese Cheesesteak
  Fresh Basil, Fresh Mozzarella, Fresh Tomatoes & Balsamic Glaze
  $16.25
- Custom Sandwich
  Create your own combination by choosing a protein and then adding to it with our range of fresh ingredients!
  $14.95
- The Rocky Cheesesteak
  Toasted Garlic Hoagie, Black Angus Beef, Home Made Marinara Sauce, Melted Mozzarella Cheese, and Fresh Basil, Topped with Shave
  $16.25
- The BBQ Pit
  Signature BBQ Sauce, Your choice of Cheese& tangy BBQ chips for you to crumble on top <b>Select Cheese but there is NO charge</b>
  $16.25
- The Vegan Cheesesteaks
  Beyond Meat, Caramelized Onions, Vegan Cheese on a Toasted Hoagie
  $18.85
- Combo
EXTREME Cheesesteak Sandwiches
- The Nacho
  Salsa, Caramelized Onions, Jalapeño Peppers and heavy Whiz, topped with crumbled Doritos
  $18.85
- The Alpha Wolf
  Large order of Crispy Bacon, Provolone Cheese, Onion Rings, Jalapeño Peppers, Signature Creamy Onion Vinaigrette
  $18.85
- The Mac & Cheese
  Mac & cheese, double order of crispy bacon, whiz
  $18.85
- The Wild Buffalo
  Hot & Spicy Buffalo Sauce, Jalapeño Peppers, Onion Rings, Blue Cheese, Carrot & Celery Slaw
  $18.85
- The Philly Hangover
  Two Fried Eggs, American Cheese, Crispy Bacon, French Fries, Crispy Onions and Peppers
  $18.85
Extras
- Fries
  HALF A POUND of crispy & fresh fries! Whiz +$2 Bacon +$2
  $9.10
- Disco Fries
  Fried potatoes, brown gravy, caramelized onions, whiz
  $11.50
- Chicken Fingers
  Homemade chicken fingers, fried crispy golden brown & served with Buffalo sauce and carrot & celery coleslaw.
  $12.95
- Bag Of Chips
  We offer an assortment of chips! Please call for our most current offerings: 914-636-7000.
  $1.95
- Onion Rings
  A perfectly seasoned large order of Onion Rings. Comes with Crotty’s Signature Creamy Onion Vinaigrette
  $10.35
- Cheesesteak Disco Fries
  Crispy Fries, Brown Gravy, Caramelized Onions, Whiz & your choice of protein.
  $18.85
- Tator Tots
  Bite-sized shredded golden potato balls! Whiz+$2
  $9.10
- Mac & Cheese
  Crotty’s uses 3 different cheeses and a homemade cheese sauce, topped with Shaved Parmesan, to take this mac and cheese OVER THE TOP!
  $6.45
- Mozzarella Sticks
  $11.65
- Crotty’s House Salad
  Mixed Greens, Tomato, Cucumber & Red Onion.
  $12.95
- Caesar Salad
  Chopped Romaine hearts, Shaved Parmesan, freshly toasted Croutons, topped with our Homemade Savory Caesar Dressing
  $12.95
Dessert
- Crotty's Signature Egg Cream
  Delicious chocolate beverage made the old-school way! *Also available in Vanilla!
  $7.15
- Cakebites Classic Italian Rainbow Cookie
  $3.90
- Cheesecake Bites
  Deep-fried, battered Cheesecake balls, covered in powdered sugar, topped with chocolate and caramel syrup
  $12.35
Beverages
- Snapple
  $3.59
- Bottle Water
  $2.95
- Bottle Soda
  Bottles are - Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Canada Dry Seltzer Water, POLAND SPRING Water, Ginger ale, Snapple Lemon Iced Tea, Snapple Mango Madness, Snapple Apple, Snapple Kiwi Strawberry & Orange Soda, Sprite & Gatorade
  $3.59
- 2 Liters
  2 Liters are - Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Crush Orange Soda, Schwepps Ginger ale & Brisk Ice Tea
  $5.20
- Crotty's Signature Egg Cream
  Delicious chocolate beverage made the old-school way! *Also available in Vanilla!
  $7.15
- Can Of Soda
  Various Flavors - Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Dr. Pepper, Crush Orange Soda, Brisk Ice Tea, Sprite, Brisk Ice Tea
  $2.29
Specials
- The Iona Gael Cheesesteak
  Traditional Cheesesteak, Eggs, French Fries and Topped With Salt, Pepper and Ketchup
  $19.45
- Cheesesteak BLT
  Black Angus Beef on a Toasted Garlic Hoagie with Lettuce, Tomato, Crispy Bacon, American Cheese & a Tangy Tartar Sauce
  $19.45
- Creamy Tomato Soup
  Comforting, Full of Rich Flavor & topped with Grated Parmesan Cheese. Delicious on its own or paired with our award winning Cheesesteak!
  $7.75
- Fried Pickle Chips With Tangy Ranch Dip
  We love the salty pickle taste with the crunchy breadcrumb coating.
  $12.95
- Meal Lover’s Crispy Baked Stuffed Potato
  Our Creamy Butter Mash topped with black Angus beef, whiz, crispy onion rings & shredded Parmesan cheese. All held by a deep fried potato shell
  $14.25
Catering
- Platters Of Hoagies
  Choice of Protein (Black Angus Beef, Grilled Chicken, Pulled Pork and/or Vegan Beyond Meat (V) ) Topped with Caramelized Onions and Smothered in Cheese Whiz on a Toasted Garlic Hoagie
  $162.50
- Traditional Mac N Cheese
  Crotty’s uses 3 different cheeses and a homemade cheese sauce, topped with Shaved Parmesan, to take this mac and cheese OVER THE TOP!
  $92.95
- Build Your Own Cheesesteak Kit
  Enjoy our Cheesesteaks at your next party with a Build Your Own Cheesesteak kit. Comes with: – 15 Hoagies – Caramelized Onions – Your choice of Protein – Large Container of Whiz
  $221.00
- Wire Basket & 2 Sterno Set-Up
  Having a party and wanting to make sure your food stays piping hot? A Wire-Basket and Sterno set-up will keep all of your hot food nice & hot! We recommend one set-up per hot food tray. The set up is your to keep.
  $15.60
- Slider
  Savory Mini Beef Patties on Fluffy Buns. Served with Lettuce, Tomato & Ketchup. $3.5 a piece. Minimum of 24.
  $78.00
- Pig In Blanket
  A party favorite, Mini Hot Dogs! Served with Sauerkraut and Sabrett Red Onions on the side.
  $71.50
- Utensils/Napkins
- Creamy Carrot And Celery Slaw
  $42.90
- Signature Salad
  Mixed Greens, Tomatoes, Pears, Dried Cranberries & Sunflower Seeds topped with Gorgonzola cheese
  $57.20
- The Caprese Salad
  Fresh mozzarella, thinly sliced tomato, iceberg lettuce and topped with fresh basil and a balsamic glaze.
  $85.80
- Crotty's Cheesesteaks Server
  Would you like help at your party? No problem! We can provide a Crotty’s Server to help with set-up, serving, cleanup and anything else you might need assistance with to make your party a huge success! *Please select number of hours. $30/hr
  $39.00
- Pizza
  Hot & Fresh Pizzeria Pizza. $100 minimum on Crotty’s food to order.
  $39.00
- Mac N Cheese Bites
  Melty, crispy, golden-brown and full of flavor. Served with Whiz on the side.
  $92.95
- Homemade Mozzarella Sticks Served With Marinara Sauce
  $65.00
- French Fries
  HALF A POUND of crispy & fresh fries!
  $57.20
- Homemade Onion Rings Served With Crotty’s Signature Dressing
  A perfectly seasoned large order of Onion Rings. Comes with Crotty’s Signature Creamy Onion Vinaigrette,
  $78.00
- Chicken Fingers
  Homemade chicken fingers, fried crispy golden brown & served with Buffalo sauce and carrot & celery coleslaw.,
  $57.20
- Fried Pickles
  We love the salty pickle taste with the crunchy breadcrumb coating. What’s not to love about a fried pickle? We serve ours with a tangy ranch dressing!
  $78.00
- Cheesecake Bites
  battered Cheesecake balls, covered in powdered sugar, topped with chocolate and caramel syrup
  $85.80
- Tator Tots
  Bite-sized shredded golBite-sized shredded golden potato balls!
  $59.80
- Caesar Salad
  Chopped Romaine hearts, Shaved Parmesan, freshly toasted Croutons, topped with our Homemade Savory Caesar Dressing
  $78.65
- Cobb Salad
  Shredded Iceberg Lettuce, Chicken, Bacon, Tomatoes, Eggs, Red Onions, Crumbled Blue Cheese
  $72.15
- Game Day Package 1
  20 Cheesesteak Sliders, Large Mac N Cheese, 2 Large Mozz Sticks, Two 2 Itr Sodas and a Choice of 1/2 tray of Salad or Fries.
  $149.50
- The EXTREME Party Package
  40 Cheesesteak Sliders, 5o Boneless Chicken Bites in Hot Sauce, Three 2 It Sodas, Full Tray Mac N Cheese and a Full Tray Salad.
  $318.50
- The Party Package
  20 Cheesesteak Sliders, 25 Boneless Chicken Bites in Hot Sauce, Two 2 It Sodas, Full Tray Mac N Cheese and a Full Tray Salad
  $221.00
- Cheesesteak Sliders
  Delicious Mini Cheesesteak Sliders! Black Angus Beef, Caramelized Onions & Whiz on Fluffy Mini Buns. Served by the dozen.
  $78.00
- Private Party Package
  Enjoy a private Chef at your next party! Our exclusive Private Party Package features everything you need for your Event to a huge success - The Food, The Grill & The Chef! Nothing for you to do but to show up and enjoy.
- Philly Cheesesteak Eggrolls & Soft Cheese Dip
  Golden-brown Egg Roll, stuffed with Steak, Whiz, Caramelized Onions.
  $71.50
Kids
- Chicken Nuggets With A Scoop Of French Fries
  $10.35
- Upside Down Grilled Cheese With A Scoop Of French Fries
  $10.35
- Traditional Cheesesteak Slider (No Onions) & Scoop Of French Fries
  $10.35

Menu Gallery

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

Privacy

Terms

Cheesesteak Sandwich EXTREME Cheesesteak Sandwiches Extras Dessert Beverages Specials Catering Kids

Cheesesteak Sandwich
- The New Yorker
  Caramelized onions, grilled tomatoes, cheddar cheese
  $16.25
- The Irishman
  Crispy bacon, caramelized onions, mushrooms, brown gravy, cheddar cheese
  $16.25
- The French Dip
  Provolone cheese, side of warm au jus for dipping
  $16.25
- The Sicilian
  Broccoli rabe, Italian hot peppers, grilled tomatoes, basil, provolone cheese
  $16.25
- The Club
  lettuce, tomato, mayo, American cheese, crispy bacon
  $16.25
- The Traditional
  Whiz, Caramelized Onions
  $14.95
- The Steakhouse Cheesesteak
  Gorgonzola Cheese, Caramelized Onions & Side of warm Au Jus for dipping
  $16.25
- Caesar Wrap Cheesesteak
  Served on a Bed of Fresh Romaine, Imported Shredded Parmesan Cheese, Topped with Crotty’s Creamy Caesar Dressing. *Can be served cold
  $16.25
- Caprese Cheesesteak
  Fresh Basil, Fresh Mozzarella, Fresh Tomatoes & Balsamic Glaze
  $16.25
- Custom Sandwich
  Create your own combination by choosing a protein and then adding to it with our range of fresh ingredients!
  $14.95
- The Rocky Cheesesteak
  Toasted Garlic Hoagie, Black Angus Beef, Home Made Marinara Sauce, Melted Mozzarella Cheese, and Fresh Basil, Topped with Shave
  $16.25
- The BBQ Pit
  Signature BBQ Sauce, Your choice of Cheese& tangy BBQ chips for you to crumble on top <b>Select Cheese but there is NO charge</b>
  $16.25
- The Vegan Cheesesteaks
  Beyond Meat, Caramelized Onions, Vegan Cheese on a Toasted Hoagie
  $18.85
- Combo
EXTREME Cheesesteak Sandwiches
- The Nacho
  Salsa, Caramelized Onions, Jalapeño Peppers and heavy Whiz, topped with crumbled Doritos
  $18.85
- The Alpha Wolf
  Large order of Crispy Bacon, Provolone Cheese, Onion Rings, Jalapeño Peppers, Signature Creamy Onion Vinaigrette
  $18.85
- The Mac & Cheese
  Mac & cheese, double order of crispy bacon, whiz
  $18.85
- The Wild Buffalo
  Hot & Spicy Buffalo Sauce, Jalapeño Peppers, Onion Rings, Blue Cheese, Carrot & Celery Slaw
  $18.85
- The Philly Hangover
  Two Fried Eggs, American Cheese, Crispy Bacon, French Fries, Crispy Onions and Peppers
  $18.85
Extras
- Fries
  HALF A POUND of crispy & fresh fries! Whiz +$2 Bacon +$2
  $9.10
- Disco Fries
  Fried potatoes, brown gravy, caramelized onions, whiz
  $11.50
- Chicken Fingers
  Homemade chicken fingers, fried crispy golden brown & served with Buffalo sauce and carrot & celery coleslaw.
  $12.95
- Bag Of Chips
  We offer an assortment of chips! Please call for our most current offerings: 914-636-7000.
  $1.95
- Onion Rings
  A perfectly seasoned large order of Onion Rings. Comes with Crotty’s Signature Creamy Onion Vinaigrette
  $10.35
- Cheesesteak Disco Fries
  Crispy Fries, Brown Gravy, Caramelized Onions, Whiz & your choice of protein.
  $18.85
- Tator Tots
  Bite-sized shredded golden potato balls! Whiz+$2
  $9.10
- Mac & Cheese
  Crotty’s uses 3 different cheeses and a homemade cheese sauce, topped with Shaved Parmesan, to take this mac and cheese OVER THE TOP!
  $6.45
- Mozzarella Sticks
  $11.65
- Crotty’s House Salad
  Mixed Greens, Tomato, Cucumber & Red Onion.
  $12.95
- Caesar Salad
  Chopped Romaine hearts, Shaved Parmesan, freshly toasted Croutons, topped with our Homemade Savory Caesar Dressing
  $12.95
Dessert
- Crotty's Signature Egg Cream
  Delicious chocolate beverage made the old-school way! *Also available in Vanilla!
  $7.15
- Cakebites Classic Italian Rainbow Cookie
  $3.90
- Cheesecake Bites
  Deep-fried, battered Cheesecake balls, covered in powdered sugar, topped with chocolate and caramel syrup
  $12.35
Beverages
- Snapple
  $3.59
- Bottle Water
  $2.95
- Bottle Soda
  Bottles are - Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Canada Dry Seltzer Water, POLAND SPRING Water, Ginger ale, Snapple Lemon Iced Tea, Snapple Mango Madness, Snapple Apple, Snapple Kiwi Strawberry & Orange Soda, Sprite & Gatorade
  $3.59
- 2 Liters
  2 Liters are - Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Crush Orange Soda, Schwepps Ginger ale & Brisk Ice Tea
  $5.20
- Crotty's Signature Egg Cream
  Delicious chocolate beverage made the old-school way! *Also available in Vanilla!
  $7.15
- Can Of Soda
  Various Flavors - Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Dr. Pepper, Crush Orange Soda, Brisk Ice Tea, Sprite, Brisk Ice Tea
  $2.29
Specials
- The Iona Gael Cheesesteak
  Traditional Cheesesteak, Eggs, French Fries and Topped With Salt, Pepper and Ketchup
  $19.45
- Cheesesteak BLT
  Black Angus Beef on a Toasted Garlic Hoagie with Lettuce, Tomato, Crispy Bacon, American Cheese & a Tangy Tartar Sauce
  $19.45
- Creamy Tomato Soup
  Comforting, Full of Rich Flavor & topped with Grated Parmesan Cheese. Delicious on its own or paired with our award winning Cheesesteak!
  $7.75
- Fried Pickle Chips With Tangy Ranch Dip
  We love the salty pickle taste with the crunchy breadcrumb coating.
  $12.95
- Meal Lover’s Crispy Baked Stuffed Potato
  Our Creamy Butter Mash topped with black Angus beef, whiz, crispy onion rings & shredded Parmesan cheese. All held by a deep fried potato shell
  $14.25
Catering
- Platters Of Hoagies
  Choice of Protein (Black Angus Beef, Grilled Chicken, Pulled Pork and/or Vegan Beyond Meat (V) ) Topped with Caramelized Onions and Smothered in Cheese Whiz on a Toasted Garlic Hoagie
  $162.50
- Traditional Mac N Cheese
  Crotty’s uses 3 different cheeses and a homemade cheese sauce, topped with Shaved Parmesan, to take this mac and cheese OVER THE TOP!
  $92.95
- Build Your Own Cheesesteak Kit
  Enjoy our Cheesesteaks at your next party with a Build Your Own Cheesesteak kit. Comes with: – 15 Hoagies – Caramelized Onions – Your choice of Protein – Large Container of Whiz
  $221.00
- Wire Basket & 2 Sterno Set-Up
  Having a party and wanting to make sure your food stays piping hot? A Wire-Basket and Sterno set-up will keep all of your hot food nice & hot! We recommend one set-up per hot food tray. The set up is your to keep.
  $15.60
- Slider
  Savory Mini Beef Patties on Fluffy Buns. Served with Lettuce, Tomato & Ketchup. $3.5 a piece. Minimum of 24.
  $78.00
- Pig In Blanket
  A party favorite, Mini Hot Dogs! Served with Sauerkraut and Sabrett Red Onions on the side.
  $71.50
- Utensils/Napkins
- Creamy Carrot And Celery Slaw
  $42.90
- Signature Salad
  Mixed Greens, Tomatoes, Pears, Dried Cranberries & Sunflower Seeds topped with Gorgonzola cheese
  $57.20
- The Caprese Salad
  Fresh mozzarella, thinly sliced tomato, iceberg lettuce and topped with fresh basil and a balsamic glaze.
  $85.80
- Crotty's Cheesesteaks Server
  Would you like help at your party? No problem! We can provide a Crotty’s Server to help with set-up, serving, cleanup and anything else you might need assistance with to make your party a huge success! *Please select number of hours. $30/hr
  $39.00
- Pizza
  Hot & Fresh Pizzeria Pizza. $100 minimum on Crotty’s food to order.
  $39.00
- Mac N Cheese Bites
  Melty, crispy, golden-brown and full of flavor. Served with Whiz on the side.
  $92.95
- Homemade Mozzarella Sticks Served With Marinara Sauce
  $65.00
- French Fries
  HALF A POUND of crispy & fresh fries!
  $57.20
- Homemade Onion Rings Served With Crotty’s Signature Dressing
  A perfectly seasoned large order of Onion Rings. Comes with Crotty’s Signature Creamy Onion Vinaigrette,
  $78.00
- Chicken Fingers
  Homemade chicken fingers, fried crispy golden brown & served with Buffalo sauce and carrot & celery coleslaw.,
  $57.20
- Fried Pickles
  We love the salty pickle taste with the crunchy breadcrumb coating. What’s not to love about a fried pickle? We serve ours with a tangy ranch dressing!
  $78.00
- Cheesecake Bites
  battered Cheesecake balls, covered in powdered sugar, topped with chocolate and caramel syrup
  $85.80
- Tator Tots
  Bite-sized shredded golBite-sized shredded golden potato balls!
  $59.80
- Caesar Salad
  Chopped Romaine hearts, Shaved Parmesan, freshly toasted Croutons, topped with our Homemade Savory Caesar Dressing
  $78.65
- Cobb Salad
  Shredded Iceberg Lettuce, Chicken, Bacon, Tomatoes, Eggs, Red Onions, Crumbled Blue Cheese
  $72.15
- Game Day Package 1
  20 Cheesesteak Sliders, Large Mac N Cheese, 2 Large Mozz Sticks, Two 2 Itr Sodas and a Choice of 1/2 tray of Salad or Fries.
  $149.50
- The EXTREME Party Package
  40 Cheesesteak Sliders, 5o Boneless Chicken Bites in Hot Sauce, Three 2 It Sodas, Full Tray Mac N Cheese and a Full Tray Salad.
  $318.50
- The Party Package
  20 Cheesesteak Sliders, 25 Boneless Chicken Bites in Hot Sauce, Two 2 It Sodas, Full Tray Mac N Cheese and a Full Tray Salad
  $221.00
- Cheesesteak Sliders
  Delicious Mini Cheesesteak Sliders! Black Angus Beef, Caramelized Onions & Whiz on Fluffy Mini Buns. Served by the dozen.
  $78.00
- Private Party Package
  Enjoy a private Chef at your next party! Our exclusive Private Party Package features everything you need for your Event to a huge success - The Food, The Grill & The Chef! Nothing for you to do but to show up and enjoy.
- Philly Cheesesteak Eggrolls & Soft Cheese Dip
  Golden-brown Egg Roll, stuffed with Steak, Whiz, Caramelized Onions.
  $71.50
Kids
- Chicken Nuggets With A Scoop Of French Fries
  $10.35
- Upside Down Grilled Cheese With A Scoop Of French Fries
  $10.35
- Traditional Cheesesteak Slider (No Onions) & Scoop Of French Fries
  $10.35

Crotty's Cheesesteaks Menu

Cheesesteak Sandwich

The New Yorker

The Irishman

The French Dip

The Sicilian

The Club

The Traditional

The Steakhouse Cheesesteak

Caesar Wrap Cheesesteak

Caprese Cheesesteak

Custom Sandwich

The Rocky Cheesesteak

The BBQ Pit

The Vegan Cheesesteaks

Combo

EXTREME Cheesesteak Sandwiches

The Nacho

The Alpha Wolf

The Mac & Cheese

The Wild Buffalo

The Philly Hangover

Extras

Fries

Disco Fries

Chicken Fingers

Bag Of Chips

Onion Rings

Cheesesteak Disco Fries

Tator Tots

Mac & Cheese

Mozzarella Sticks

Crotty’s House Salad

Caesar Salad

Dessert

Crotty's Signature Egg Cream

Cakebites Classic Italian Rainbow Cookie

Cheesecake Bites

Beverages

Snapple

Bottle Water

Bottle Soda

2 Liters

Crotty's Signature Egg Cream

Can Of Soda

Specials

The Iona Gael Cheesesteak

Cheesesteak BLT

Creamy Tomato Soup

Fried Pickle Chips With Tangy Ranch Dip

Meal Lover’s Crispy Baked Stuffed Potato

Catering

Platters Of Hoagies

Traditional Mac N Cheese

Build Your Own Cheesesteak Kit

Wire Basket & 2 Sterno Set-Up

Slider

Pig In Blanket

Utensils/Napkins

Creamy Carrot And Celery Slaw

Signature Salad

The Caprese Salad

Crotty's Cheesesteaks Server

Pizza

Mac N Cheese Bites

Homemade Mozzarella Sticks Served With Marinara Sauce

French Fries

Homemade Onion Rings Served With Crotty’s Signature Dressing

Chicken Fingers

Fried Pickles

Cheesecake Bites

Tator Tots

Caesar Salad

Cobb Salad

Game Day Package 1

The EXTREME Party Package

The Party Package

Cheesesteak Sliders

Private Party Package

Philly Cheesesteak Eggrolls & Soft Cheese Dip