Cottage Inn Pizza Hilliard

AHHHHMAZINGG! This is literally my FAVORITE pizza of all time. Sausage and pepperoni with their delicious RANCH. You won't go wrong!!! I pre ordered by calling on the phone. It was ready in time and kept warm. My go-to everytime I'm in Columbus or Michigan.

The food was pretty good, but the delivery driver forgot half our food at the restaurant then told me "no" when I said he didn't give us all our food even though I showed him the receipt in my hand. He then realized he did indeed forget our food and went back to get the rest of our food and bring it to us. I was pretty annoyed I paid a tip before hand on my card since he was not very pleasant. I called the restaurant and they were pretty nice about it and said he would bring the rest of the food.

I got a good vibe as soon as I walked in the door- hole-in-the-wall place, smell of pizza ovens, and a jolly guy running the counter who's all smiles? And if that weren't enough, the pizza is AMAZING- one bite and I was in heaven. And a really good price- less than $15 and it fed me and my partner easily.

Don’t recommend the 8 pc boneless for $11.00 bucks taste like a frozen kids meal nugget.

Not the place for Gluten Free pizza. Recently ordered from this location for a delivery. I received the pizzas in a timely manner and the delivery driver was nice. I ordered a medium hand tossed and a gluten free pizza. The Medium hand tossed pizza was delicious! However, the Gluten Free crust leaves a lot to be desired. The dough was extremely thin and there was no outside crust. It was flimsy and not crunchy at all. My girlfriend who has a gluten sensitivity ended up just scraping the toppings off of the dough and ate it that way instead. We have had GF pizza from Dominoes, Donatos, and even frozen digiorno pizza. All of them are preferable to the Gluten Free option here. The regular dough and pizza is VERY good, but I would go elsewhere for gluten free.

Toppings on pizza were very light. Talked to manager about issue no results.

The food is delicious and the family working in there is so kind and has great customer service!