Cosentino's Pizza

Seriously good pizza and not expensive for the quality. Had the supreme xl and it was great. Very little grease for how much meat was used. It shows they use quality ingredients

Love the pizza here! Amazing

Great authentic margarita pizza. Authentic Italian. Great guys in the kitchen!

Just tried Cosentino's for the first time. Ordered the build your own and they did not miss a step . This is one of the best pizzas I've had in a very long time.... Great quality, affordable pricing . Highly recommend

This is the first time coming here after “Big O To Go” was sold. I am happy to say that the pizza, wings and salad were incredible. The new owner is very nice and he makes a lot of what he serves from scratch. The homemade ranch was awesome. The salad and toppings were very fresh and the pizza was terrific. I highly recommend Constentino’s and I think it would be amazing to have another pizzeria stay in business for 40 years like Big O did.

Wow why on earth would you change perfection??? Big o pizza was the best pizza ever. Been going for 40 years. The only way to improve your food is to scrap the entire menu and go back to Big O recipes and menu items. I’m so sick of heart, this is so sad

Decided to try lunch delivered today from Cosentino's in Mission Viejo. We ordered the antipasto salad, meatballs, chicken wings, and mozzarella sticks. The food was packaged quite nicely and very tasty. The customer service and delivery were perfect, and of course, eating at home the ambiance was just wonderful. Great find, and I will definitely be back to order one of their signature pizzas. Recommended.

First time ordering from this place and it was awful. Our mozzarella sticks arrived and all the cheese from the inside was stuck to the bottom of the box. The garlic knots had no flavor. They were just bread knots that were burnt at the top, and the pizza was extremely salty. Would never order form here again.

Best calzone we ever tasted. Began with friendly and knowledgeable service from the counter attendant. Big salad which we ate while our calzone order was made up from scratch. Got to watch them assemble and bake. Calzone turned several times in the oven--not many places do this. This is a take out place with a couple of tables, so "atmosphere" a little lacking. Again, best calzone we ever tasted.

I have ordered and eaten here several times but the last couple times I have ordered from them on the weekend the quality of the pizza has been terrible. I always get the White Garlic Pizza with the Wedge Salad and this is the 2nd time the pizza crust has been soggy in the middle and doesn't seem cooked all the way. Also, the cheese slides right off the pizza and had the consistency of rubber. The salad was also not the quality of what I have usually gotten from here. Lettuce is fine but the toppings left a lot to be desired. Not sure what has changed in the past few months here and hate to complain but thought it needed to be heard.