Conestoga Steak House

The best steak I’ve had in years, or possibly ever! I always order my steak tips well done, which can be risky, but these were amazingly tender, juicy and flavorful! The homemade rolls were delicious too. The only reason I did not give 5 stars, is the fact that they do not have real butter for those amazing rolls. That is doing a disservice to those rolls. I should also add that the atmosphere is lacking. It is old school, bare bones.

Long wait time...but my steak was excellant!!

Great food great staff, im gonna be dining here every week

Hands down the best steak in Dothan and probably best steak in Alabama. The place is not fancy and they don't have a big bar.... I didn't see a bar at all. Their menu is simple. You pick your steak cut and tell them the temp you want it and sit there and wait for the best steak you will probably ever have. The side dishes are typical offerings, and they are good. The prices are very reasonable here. The service is very good here. If steak is what you want, there is no better place in Dothan to get it.

Steak was awful. Service was great. Ordered a sirloin but I got a ribeye. If ur looking for a great steak go to Big Mikes in Andalusia !!! This place needs some serious help!

My lady treated me to me to dinner the steak was delicious and tender. My lady played some piano jazz on her phone because they didn't have any music playing. Other customers were wondering where the music is coming from. As some people left they said you're the ones with the music.

Awesome