City Island Pizza Company

Love

They are so amazing

Atmosphere was phenomenal and the service was great. Super welcoming and open. Pizza was a miss it was cooked well and the crust tasted great but unfortunately somewhat bland couldn't really identify the flavors within each bite Chicken scarp was cooked really well and would order that again. Nice mix of flavor Brussel sprouts were my favorite. Would I come back.....Yes. But deff not my first choice. Will come back to try out the pastas

Definitely the best pizza on city island, full pies only, but very worth it. So far, I haven't had anything I didn't like

What a beautiful evening. Took my wife out for date night here and it was perfect. From Tevin the waiter to Kerri the manger and rest of staff just attentive and welcoming. Food was cook to perfection and was not rushed…. And to end the evening, their tiramisu ice cream was to die for. Thank you city island team for a great experience . All the best and much success to you guys. I see nothing less.

We made spur of the moment dinner reservations for a Sunday evening. The chef/owner Rene and his team did a wonderful job in making us feeling at home, meeting our special requests and creating an overall memorable experience. What a great local spot that we look forward to returning to in the near future! Glad to have a convenient high quality restaurant join the City Island community! Dietary restrictions: More than willing to accommodate dietary restrictions/allergies