City Feed and Supply

I’ve been wanting to try this place because it looked pretty good from the outside…it is not. Very basic items for an outrageous price, might as well go to Whole Foods, they would actually be cheaper. What really got me though was them asking for a tip and it wasn’t a tip for a sandwich that was made, it was a tip on a single grocery item that I bought. So basically they wanted a tip for me coming inside, picking out subpar brownies and paying for them. The brownies were also awful

Took them 15 minutes to slice a bagel and put cream cheese on it and even then they still weren’t done!

UPDATE: the owner of city feed received well my review and critic and he refunded the sandwiches. I am happy that they paid attention to the customers and reached out. Looking forward to enjoy their delicious sandwiches in the future. Leaving my previous review for accountability purposes. ‐-------------- On 12/31 my husband and I went to City Feed for our last lunch of the year, craving their delicious Italian sandwiches. Unfortunately, to our disappointment, we received bagels instead of the regular bread we expected. The total cost for both sandwiches was almost $30, and we were more than willing to pay for them, as it was a special treat for us. Additionally, we purchased a pumpkin pie and cheese to support the business, bringing our total bill to $70. I originally tried to reach out through an Instagram message because we noticed a crowd at the business, and we didn't want to cause any inconvenience for the employee(s) responsible for making the sandwiches or taking our order. ...But,they didn't see their message despite of have more recent posts... It would have been appreciated if we were informed that they were out of the regular bread, allowing us to decide whether we wanted the alternative or choose a different sandwich. I believe this is the minimum expectation for an order, especially when each sandwich costs around $15.

Great neighborhood place; I go for the lox and bagel sandwich. Prices are very expensive.

Great little store in the heart of JP. People are really nice and there is a good selection of grocery items. While everything is very expensive, it is high quality.

Great place for a quick sandwich! Delicious food