Cincinnati Good Fellows Menu

4.5

(600+ Reviews)

$Pizza, Sports bar

Desserts Pasta Sides/Sauces Tacos Soft Drinks Kid's Menu Salads 16" Pizzas Bites 9" Pizzas Calzones 12" Pizzas

Desserts
- Maggie's Cinnamon Sticks
  Made with fresh pizza dough, butter, cinnamon, sugar, side of warmed cannoli filling.
  $8.80
- Piper's Cannoli
  Four mini Italian pastries filled with our own special sweet ricotta, with chocolate chips, whipped cream, chocolate, caramel syrup.
  $8.80
- Steveo's S'mores Pizza
  Fresh pizza dough, Nutella, marshmallows, crumbled graham crackers, chocolate syrup.
  $11.00
- Larry's Ice Cream Sundae
  Two scoops of ice cream, whipped cream, chocolate syrup, cherry on top.
  $5.50
Pasta
- Scott's Spaghetti
  Goodfellow's signature marinara, parmesan, GF spice.
  $7.70
Sides/Sauces
- Waffle Fries
  $4.40
- Cole Slaw
  $2.20
- BBQ Grippos (Bag)
  $1.05
- Lay's Chips (Bag)
  $1.05
Tacos
- Mr. Anderson (2 To Order)
  Pulled pork, onion, Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ, BBQ Grippo's.
  $8.80
- King Caleb (2 To Order)
  Chicken, house cheese blend, onion, tomato, Hot Garlic Parmesan sauce, creamy pesto, mixed greens.
  $8.80
- Kelly Belly (2 To Order)
  Meatballs, house cheese blend, parmesan, fresh basil.
  $8.80
- Jones (2 To Order)
  Pulled pork, Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ, cheddar cheese.
  $8.80
- Kari's Black Bean (2 To Order)
  Chopped black bean burger, house cheese blend, onion, tomato, lettuce, creamy pesto.
  $8.80
Soft Drinks
- Coke
  $2.20
- Root Beer
  $2.20
- Ginger Ale
  $2.20
- Diet Coke
  $2.20
- Sugar Free Red Bull
  $4.70
- Iced Tea
  $2.20
- Juice
  $2.20
- Pink Lemonade
  $2.20
- Red Bull
  $4.70
- Mountain Dew
  $2.20
- Sprite
  $2.20
Kid's Menu
- Cheese Pizza (8")
  Includes drink.
  $7.70
- Meatballs
  Two meatballs with garlic toast and drink.
  $7.70
Salads
- Grandma Vera's (Full)
  Mixed greens, ham, turkey, capicola, tomato, onion, egg, cheddar, croutons, balsamic dressing.
  $12.10
- House (Side)
  Mixed greens, cheddar cheese, tomato, onion, egg, croutons, and choice of dressing on the side.
  $5.50
- Wedge
  Lettuce wedge topped with ranch, tomato, green pepper, bacon.
  $7.70
- House (Full)
  Mixed greens, cheddar cheese, tomato, onion, egg, croutons, and choice of dressing on the side.
  $8.80
- Godfather (Side)
  Mixed greens, cheese blend, capicola, pepperoni, ham, tomato, onion, green pepper, banana pepper, black olive, green olive, jalapenos, swirl of mustard, GF spices, croutons, Italian dressing.
  $8.80
- Mama Mac (Full)
  Mixed greens, pulled pork, onion, feta cheese, croutons, hot bacon dressing.
  $12.10
- Jaime B's (Full)
  Mixed greens, basil, egg, tomato, black olive, chopped black bean burger, blue cheese crumbles, ranch dressing.
  $13.20
- Godfather (Full)
  Mixed greens, cheese blend, capicola, pepperoni, ham, tomato, onion, green pepper, banana pepper, black olive, green olive, jalapenos, swirl of mustard, GF spices, croutons, Italian dressing.
  $14.30
- Grandma Vera's (Side)
  Mixed greens, ham, turkey, capicola, tomato, onion, egg, cheddar, croutons, balsamic dressing.
  $7.70
- Jaime B's (Side)
  Mixed greens, basil, egg, tomato, black olive, chopped black bean burger, blue cheese crumbles, ranch dressing.
  $8.80
- Mama Mac (Side)
  Mixed greens, pulled pork, onion, feta cheese, croutons, hot bacon dressing.
  $7.70
- Stormy's Turkey (Side)
  Mixed greens, smoked turkey, bacon, onion, tomato, egg, cheddar cheese, croutons, honey mustard dressing.
  $7.70
- Stormy's Turkey (Full)
  Mixed greens, smoked turkey, bacon, onion, tomato, egg, cheddar cheese, croutons, honey mustard dressing.
  $12.10
16" Pizzas
- Ace
  Pesto, Italian sausage, onion, green pepper.
  $26.40
- Alex's BBQ Grippo
  Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ, chicken, bacon, onion, topped with crushed BBQ Grippo's chips.
  $28.60
- Bella Maria
  Olive oil, garlic, tomato, basil, feta.
  $26.40
- Brent The Bull
  Pizza sauce, pepperoni, sausage, capicola, bacon.
  $26.40
- Cheese/Create Your Own
  Hand tossed with crushed red tomato sauce, 50/50 blend mozz & prov, topped with 9 blend GF spice.
  $17.60
- Debbie's Veggie
  Pesto, onion, tomato, green pepper, mushrooms, banana pepper, black olive, green olive.
  $28.60
- Goodfellow
  Pizza sauce, capicola, sausage, onion, green pepper, tomato, mushroom, banana pepper, green & black olives, pineapple, bacon, pepperoni.
  $30.80
- Hot Garlic Parmesan
  HGP sauce, chicken, onion, banana pepper, topped with swirl of ranch dressing.
  $26.40
- Jacob's Inferno
  Pizza Sauce, onion, green pepper, jalapeno, habanero.
  $26.40
- Kristina's Kindness
  Olive oil, garlic, capicola, tomato, mushroom, blue chees crumbles.
  $28.60
- Leta Fajita
  Spicy garlic ranch, chicken, tomato, onion, jalapenos, cheddar, topped with swirl of sour cream.
  $26.40
- Louie's Love
  Olive oil, garlic, artichoke hearts, banana pepper, black olive, goat cheese.
  $28.60
- Lucky Luke
  Pizza sauce, bacon, sausage, onion, pickles, cheddar, with a swirl of mustard.
  $28.60
- Malia's Hawaiian
  Pizza sauce, capicola, green pepper, pineapple.
  $26.40
- Pat's Meatball
  Marinara sauce, sliced meatballs, onion, basil.
  $28.60
- Red Tony
  Pizza sauce on top of sliced provolone, parmesan.
  $23.10
- Simpson's Way
  Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ sauce, pulled pork, bacon, pineapple, topped with crushed BBQ Grippo's chips.
  $28.60
Bites
- Tre's Bacon Skins
  Potato skins (5) filled with bacon, cheddar cheese, side of sour cream.
  $9.90
- Shelia's Soft Baked Pretzel (Regular)
  Choice of side: nacho cheese, honey mustard, dijon mustard, dijonnaise, pizza sauce.
  $7.70
- Italian Sticks
  Fresh pizza dough, cheese and GF spices, side of marinara.
  $6.60
- Baked Wings (10 To Order)
  Cajun baked wings with sauce on the side. Choice of celery or baby carrots.
- Blake's Pepp Balls (5 To Order)
  Pepperoni wrapped in pizza dough with fresh garlic, butter, parmesan, GF spices, side of marinara.
  $7.70
- Baked Wings (5 To Order)
  Cajun baked wings with sauce on the side. Choice of celery or baby carrots.
- Jonny's Pepperoni Chips
  Crispy chips seasoned with GF spice and parmesan, side of ranch.
  $6.60
- Ruby's Garlic Bread
  Garlic butter, parmesan, GF spices, side of marinara sauce.
  $6.60
- Diane's Nachos
  Corn tortilla chips, lettuce, chili, cheddar cheese, tomato, onion, jalapeño.
  $12.10
- T.J.'S Meatballs & Toast (3 To Order)
  Meatballs topped with parmesan, GF spices, side of garlic toast.
  $8.80
- Diamond's Deathbed Coleslaw
  There’s only one way anyone will get the recipe!
  $4.40
- Conner's Veggie Skins
  Potato skins (5) filled with banana pepper, goat cheese, black olive, cheddar cheese, drizzle of spicy garlic ranch, side of sour cream.
  $11.00
- Bobby's Meatball Chili
  House made beef & pork chili, garlic, onion, parmesan, house blend cheese, Italian croutons, basil.
  $6.60
- Shelia's Soft Baked Pretzel (Jumbo)
  Choice of side: nacho cheese, honey mustard, dijon mustard, dijonnaise, pizza sauce.
  $17.60
- Tim & Shirley's Antipasto
  Capicola, pepperoni, ham, provolone, cheddar, carrot, green pepper, pickle, celery, green olive, tomato, basil, drizzle of olive oil, GF spice, side of Italian dressing.
  $13.20
- T.J.'S Meatballs & Toast (4 To Order)
  Meatballs topped with parmesan, GF spices, side of garlic toast.
  $11.00
- Blake's Pepp Balls (10 To Order)
  Pepperoni wrapped in pizza dough with fresh garlic, butter, parmesan, GF spices, side of marinara.
  $13.20
9" Pizzas
- Ace
  Pesto, Italian sausage, onion, green pepper.
- Alex's BBQ Grippo
  Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ, chicken, bacon, onion, topped with crushed BBQ Grippo's chips.
- Bella Maria
  Olive oil, garlic, tomato, basil, feta.
- Brent The Bull
  Pizza sauce, pepperoni, sausage, capicola, bacon.
- Cheese/Create Your Own
  Hand tossed with crushed red tomato sauce, 50/50 blend mozz & prov, topped with 9 blend GF spice.
- Debbie's Veggie
  Pesto, onion, tomato, green pepper, mushrooms, banana pepper, black olive, green olive.
- Goodfellow
  Pizza sauce, capicola, sausage, onion, green pepper, tomato, mushroom, banana pepper, green & black olives, pineapple, bacon, pepperoni.
- Hot Garlic Parmesan
  HGP sauce, chicken, onion, banana pepper, topped with swirl of ranch dressing.
- Jacob's Inferno
  Pizza Sauce, onion, green pepper, jalapeno, habanero.
- Kristina's Kindness
  Olive oil, garlic, capicola, tomato, mushroom, blue chees crumbles.
- Leta Fajita
  Spicy garlic ranch, chicken, tomato, onion, jalapenos, cheddar, topped with swirl of sour cream.
- Louie's Love
  Olive oil, garlic, artichoke hearts, banana pepper, black olive, goat cheese.
- Lucky Luke
  Pizza sauce, bacon, sausage, onion, pickles, cheddar, with a swirl of mustard.
- Malia's Hawaiian
  Pizza sauce, capicola, green pepper, pineapple.
- Pat's Meatball
  Marinara sauce, sliced meatballs, onion, basil.
- Red Tony
  Pizza sauce on top of sliced provolone, parmesan.
- Simpson's Way
  Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ sauce, pulled pork, bacon, pineapple, topped with crushed BBQ Grippo's chips.
Calzones
- Cheese/Build Your Own
  Toppings each $1.25, signature toppings each $1.75.
  $8.00
- Kloe's Five Cheese
  Parmesan, mozzarella, provolone, feta, goat cheese.
  $10.00
- Schriber Zone
  Pepperoni, capicola, onion, goat cheese.
  $12.00
- Nicki's Basil Tomato
  Garlic, olive oil, fresh basil, tomato.
  $10.00
- Kendall's Spicy Pork
  Pulled pork, onion, jalapeno, spicy garlic ranch.
  $12.00
- Phenix's Pesto
  Banana pepper, onion, mushroom, tomato, pesto.
  $12.00
- Jamesaroni
  Capicola, onion, sun-dried tomato, pesto.
  $10.00
12" Pizzas
- Ace
  Pesto, Italian sausage, onion, green pepper.
  $19.80
- Alex's BBQ Grippo
  Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ, chicken, bacon, onion, topped with crushed BBQ Grippo's chips.
  $22.00
- Bella Maria
  Olive oil, garlic, tomato, basil, feta.
  $19.80
- Brent The Bull
  Pizza sauce, pepperoni, sausage, capicola, bacon.
  $19.80
- Cheese/Create Your Own
  Hand tossed with crushed red tomato sauce, 50/50 blend mozz & prov, topped with 9 blend GF spice.
  $14.30
- Debbie's Veggie
  Pesto, onion, tomato, green pepper, mushrooms, banana pepper, black olive, green olive.
  $19.80
- Goodfellow
  Pizza sauce, capicola, sausage, onion, green pepper, tomato, mushroom, banana pepper, green & black olives, pineapple, bacon, pepperoni.
  $24.20
- Hot Garlic Parmesan
  HGP sauce, chicken, onion, banana pepper, topped with swirl of ranch dressing.
  $19.80
- Jacob's Inferno
  Pizza Sauce, onion, green pepper, jalapeno, habanero.
  $19.80
- Kristina's Kindness
  Olive oil, garlic, capicola, tomato, mushroom, blue chees crumbles.
  $22.00
- Leta Fajita
  Spicy garlic ranch, chicken, tomato, onion, jalapenos, cheddar, topped with swirl of sour cream.
  $19.80
- Louie's Love
  Olive oil, garlic, artichoke hearts, banana pepper, black olive, goat cheese.
  $22.00
- Lucky Luke
  Pizza sauce, bacon, sausage, onion, pickles, cheddar, with a swirl of mustard.
  $22.00
- Malia's Hawaiian
  Pizza sauce, capicola, green pepper, pineapple.
  $19.80
- Pat's Meatball
  Marinara sauce, sliced meatballs, onion, basil.
  $18.70
- Red Tony
  Pizza sauce on top of sliced provolone, parmesan.
  $18.70
- Simpson's Way
  Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ sauce, pulled pork, bacon, pineapple, topped with crushed BBQ Grippo's chips.
  $22.00