Cestra's Pizza 4

My new go-to for pizza in New Rochelle. Buffalo chicken slice is legit and the garlic knots are very good. I’ve had the calzone as well which has a nice crispy bake to the outside. Have had fries and calamari as well - nothing has missed the mark yet.

The eggplant pizza is AMAZING!!!! I thought it was a chicken slice, just delicious!!! The costumer service is great! Vegetarian options: All of their food is GREAT & Delicious!!! Vegetarian as well.

Best food in all of westchester bar none

It was so delicious here

Just moved to New Rochelle. Looking to find my new ‘local’ spot. Stopped here with the fam. Ordered a slice, a kids pasta, and a Sicilian pie. $50. The Sicilian pie was $34!!! For eight slices. Little baby Sicilian! Lol. Ouch. The staff was cool. But I’m used to a regular sized Sicilian. And definitely NOT for $34!!! The search continues…

I’ve been going to this spot for a few years and the service is great Musa always has my order hot and fresh I highly recommend them.

If you’re looking for an official NY slice, this is the spot! The pizza is perfectly crispy and flavorful, good tasting homemade sauce and any topping you can imagine. All other appetizers are on point and the staff is friendly. I honestly can’t get enough of this place! Highly recommended - 10/10

Cestra’s pizza is the best in New Rochelle. Always comes in clutch with the best food and service.