Cathy's: Gourmet Ice Cream Sandwiches

4.3
(97 Reviews)
Permanently closed
  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo

Ratings of Cathy's: Gourmet Ice Cream Sandwiches

google
Google
4.2
(69 Reviews)
yelp
Yelp
4.4
(28 Reviews)

Happy Hours & Specials

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?


Photos

  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo

Location & Hours


Recent Reviews

google
Mar 2023
Ice cream and cookies are delicious but the combination of warm cookies plus ice cream in a paper bag gives you about 90s to eat before it disintegrates.
google
Mar 2023
Tried to get ice cream at 9pm on Saturday when they close at 11pm, cashier had very rude attitude and didn’t provide service!
google
Mar 2023
This is the best Cathy’s !!
google
Mar 2023
Everything is phenomenal. Ice cream is great, cookies are good. My ONLY COMPLAINT and the reason it only gets 4 stars is this: SELL THE HARDER COOKIES!!! I respect your decision to have all of your cookies to be soft and sweet for ice cream sandwiches. (It's even their tag line!) But if I'm buying JUST the cookie??? I prefer it to have more body/resistance. It's super soft/gooey/doughy in the middle which can be off putting. So sell the harder ones atleast on request! I'll take them off of you, I promise I won't be angry even if they're really tough. It's what I asked for . That being said, if any of you wish to buy JUST the cookies but aren't a fan of the texture when it's eaten alone, throw it in the oven for a bit. It brings it right up to perfect cookie texture and temp . Still highly recommend and I stop by every once in a while to enjoy an ice cream sandwich.
google
Mar 2023
Donimic and Nevaeh were the best! Ice cream was good but the service was better. This is my ice cream spot from now on!
google
Mar 2023
First-time visit attempt. Employees posted “taking a break” sign at 9:20pm on a Saturday with inconclusive return time, door locked, no customers, while both employees are present in the store, just hanging about. Have not actually eaten ice cream here, and never will. Went across the street to Five Guys for a shake.
google
Mar 2023
Nevaeh Had me trying flavorsss! I usually get cookies & cream, playing it safe but she got me out of my comfort zone and put me on!! She was so fun & inviting. She made my day! Along with this yummy ice cream, I got strawberry cheesecake, YUM!
google
Mar 2023
Wow first impressions are everything! This was our first time here and we are in love. Big ice cream fanatics and. Our girl Dominique hooked it up! Everything was 10 stars! We will be back every week.
google
Mar 2023
I only went to this location because the other one has closed down. First experience was fine except they were out of chocolate chip cookies. This location had me appalled! They were out of the ice cream I wanted and only had 2 cookies to choose from, so when I finally settled on something, the young lady told me it would be 15m for a fresh batch of cookies. So I step outside and wait. I come back in and now another teenager, a guy, tells me it's gonna be 30m and appeared to be annoyed that I was back in there. These teenagers had the most obscene music playing loud and didn't turn it off when I walked in. I guess I was disturbing their party. I just decided to leave. My wife tried to call several times weeks before our visit and no one ever answered the phone, nor responded to her IG message or email. Very disappointed, I won't be returning. This young staff needs a lesson in customer service, the store needs a manager on duty, and they need to keep ice cream and cookies in stock. After all, isn't that what they supposed to sell?


Nearby Locations

Loading...

(404) 902-3812

855 Peachtree St NE, Atlanta, GA 30308