Proper Pizza New York

The restaurant was very clean, staff was extremely friendly, and food was amazing. I would 100% recommend this as your go-to pizza spot in the bronx.

My sibling and I wanted to wander in the cool breeze of Arthur Ave in the early Fall, and we stumbled upon a new pizzeria that opened three months ago. We were curious to try it out, so we ordered our delicious cheese slices with pepperoni. Meanwhile, we noticed that they have a wooden homely vibe, a plushy lounge, and a large flat screen TV displaying sharp visuals and playing the trendiest alternative music. The friendly cashier explained how to order Personal Pies, custom made with different flavors. The food was delicious and I enjoyed the warm vibe. Unexpectedly, the cashier wanted my sibling and I to eat a new Margarita-flavored pizza for testing - on the house! After giving my suggestion, he told me to come back for Number 9: Proper Pizza. Some of the flavors are shown in the photos. Come to Proper Pizza in Arthur Ave! Next week later, my sibling and I tried the Proper Pizza and the Garlic Bread and Cheese, which happens to be another Pizza! Cheers to Proper Pizza in Arthur Ave! Two months later, I decided to stop by on my own and ordered a Margherita Pizza. The associate told me of a promotional 8-inch Pizza Pie, but it is only for Cheese and Pepperoni flavors. As always, the restaurant is beautifully decorated, and all their flavors are delicious. Vegetarian options: Some vegetarian options include the 4 Cheese Pizza or the Nutella Pizza Pies. Kid-friendliness: I have witnessed children happily eating their delicious share of pizza with their parents. Yes, children can easily fit into this warm, welcoming pizzeria.

The most delicious pizzas Yesterday I visited Proper Pizza for the first time and had a wonderful experience The staff was very friendly and welcoming I would definitely recommend Proper Pizza to anyone looking for a great pizza place.

I will be going back and telling my friends they have speciality pizzas made to order my friend enjoyed the tuna pizza

What can I say it's a chill place to eat pizza this piece of brought back a childhood memeries

Always the best experience, the pizzas are amazing you must try their signature proper Pizza, It's me to perfection! The Host Emma is the best

I recently had the pleasure of ordering from Proper Pizza for my students. It was an exceptional experience. Agon is a delightful person. He was incredibly friendly and attentive, ensuring that every aspect of our dining experience was enjoyable. He was accommodating towards my school principal and I. He explained the best options for our students and was honest and helpful the entire time. The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside and delightfully chewy on the inside. Each bite was a burst of flavor, with fresh ingredients that spoke to the quality of their offerings. Whether you're a fan of classic Margherita or adventurous with unique combinations, this pizzeria caters to all tastes. My students, the teachers, and staff all enjoyed the pizza. Even our picky eaters were glad to take part in the pizza party. Proper Pizza has earned its place as our go-to spot for a pizza. I highly recommend it.

Great pizza, awesome customer service and a nice cozy place to chill with friends and eat. Definitely recommend you all stop by and give them a try

Amazing pizza if you’re in the area you need to come here and try it out