Ratings of Cataldo's Restaurant & Pizzeria
Google
4.5
(298 Reviews)
Yelp
4.2
(260 Reviews)
TripAdvisor
4.5
(39 Reviews)
Photos
Location & Hours
Homestyle Italian cooking & wood-fired pizzas pair with house wines at this casual, family-run spot.
554 Vanderbilt Ave #1
Brooklyn, NY 11238
554 Vanderbilt Ave #1
Brooklyn, NY 11238
Recent Reviews
Jul 2023
I loved this place so much. Sadly, they closed permanently several weeks ago (the owners retired). Not sure why Google Maps isn’t listing that accurately.
Jun 2023
Absolutely Amazing Pizzas!! Best crust ever
Jun 2023
Honestly, the best of the best. Mi amori! Salute! Excellente! The seafood is great! All the food is great. GOD BLESS BROOKLYN! I do not own the restaurant.
May 2023
My roommate and I order from Cataldo’s at least once per week. The food is amazing, very reasonable prices, the staff is great.
May 2023
Good food, very homey
May 2023
Just fantastic! Solid food. Amazing value and the staff is hilarious and so hospitable. Just a great feel good place
May 2023
Nice Italian restaurant. Our server was fun, attentive, and so accommodating. Food was good and came out hot and quick.
Apr 2023
Amazing red sauce Italian in prospect heights !
Apr 2023
Great place!
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Cataldo's Restaurant & Pizzeria's rating?
Cataldo's Restaurant & Pizzeria is rated an average of 4.4/5 stars across various online platforms.