Castaways Menu

$$Pizza, Restaurant, Seafood

1500 N High St, Lancaster, OH 43130

Suggest Edit

Appetizers
- Chilled Shrimp Cocktail
  A classic favorite! 6 Jumbo Shrimp served with cocktail sauce.
  $6.00
- Loaded Potato Skins
  6 skins stuffed with provolone cheese, bacon, and scallions, with sour cream.
  $10.00
- Breaded Chicken Tenders
  6 white meat tenders served with ranch, BBQ, honey mustard.
  $10.00
- Cheese Sticks
  6 breaded cheese sticks, deep fried to perfection! Served with pizza sauce.
  $8.00
- Basket Of 21 Shrimp
  Fried golden brown and served with cocktail sauce.
  $11.00
- Basket Of Oysters
  Hand breaded, fresh oysters! Served with cocktail sauce.
  $15.00
- Basket Of Onion Rings
  A generous portion of our jumbo onion rings served with ranch dressing.
  $11.00
- Basket Of Fries
  Deep fried to a golden brown. More than enough to share!
  $10.00
Dinner Salads
- Chef's Salad
  A large garden salad topped with ham, turkey, Swiss cheese, egg, tomatoes, and croutons.
  $12.00
- Shrimp Salad
  A large garden salad topped with shrimp, Swiss cheese, egg, tomatoes, and croutons.
  $12.00
- Grilled Chicken Salad
  A large garden salad topped with chicken, bacon, egg, tomatoes, and croutons.
  $13.00
- Steak Salad
  A large garden topped with beef tenderloin, scallions, tomatoes, croutons.
  $14.00
Just For Kids
- Cheeseburger & Fries
  $8.00
- Chicken Tenders & Fries
  $6.00
- Fried Shrimp & Fries
  $9.00
- Sirloin Steak & Fries
  $10.00
Main Fare
- House Special* Sirloin Steak For Two
  It's what we are famous for! Choice cuts of mouthwatering Sirloin Steak served family style.
  $36.00
- Sirloin Steak For 3 Or More
  $19.00
- Sirloin Steak For One
  $22.00
- Porterhouse Steak
  The Great Steak Lovers Choice! A 16 oz cut, grilled to your liking.
  $28.00
- Y. Strip Steak
  A generous 16 oz boneless cut grilled to your liking.
  $28.00
- 10 Oz Filet Mignon
  A huge 10 oz cut smothered with mushrooms. The Best!
  $30.00
- 8 Oz Filet Mignon
  An 8 oz Filet served with a skewer of shrimp scampi.
  $30.00
- Sirloin Steak And Shrimp
  8 ounces of Sirloin and 3 fried jumbo shrimp. Served with cocktail sauce.
  $27.00
- Boneless Ribeye Steak
  A 16 oz hearty cut.
  $28.00
- Ground Round Steak
  An 8 oz patty of freshly ground round. Smothered with grilled onions.
  $13.00
- Boneless Pork Tenderloin
  Two juicy center cut chops, grilled just right.
  $12.00
- Center Cut Ham Steak
  A generous slice of Bay's smoked whole ham.
  $13.00
- Deluxe Chicken
  A 6 oz boneless breast topped with Swiss cheese, mushrooms, and bacon.
  $15.00
- Grilled Chicken Breast
  A deliciously seasoned 6 oz boneless breast seared to a golden brown.
  $14.00
- Breaded Chicken Tenders
  4 white meat tenders served with your choice of ranch, BBQ, or honey mustard.
  $12.00
Sandwiches
- Castaways Specials
  An American favorite! A big burger topped with cheese, lettuce, tomato, & onion.
  $9.00
- Chicken Sandwich
  Boneless all white meat chicken topped with lettuce, tomato, & onion.
  $10.00
- Grilled Sausage Sandwich
  A 1/4 pound patty of original sausage from Bay Food Market. Served with a slice of onion.
  $8.00
- Mushroom, Onion & Swiss
  A burger topped with grilled mushrooms, onions and Swiss cheese.
  $10.00
- Fish Fillet Sandwich
  North Atlantic Haddock served with our own tartar sauce.
  $7.00
- Oyster Sandwich
  Hand breaded, fresh oysters served with our own tartar or cocktail sauce.
  $8.00
Our Signature 12" Stone Baked Pizzas!
- Cheese Pizza
  $12.00
- Pepperoni Pizza
  $13.00
- Works Pizza
  Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Onions, Green Peppers or Banana Peppers.
  $16.00
Create Your Own Pizza
- Meat Toppings
  Pepperoni, Ham, Sausage, Hamburger, & Bacon.
  $2.00
- Veggie Toppings
  Mushrooms, Onions, Black Olives, Green Olives, Jalapeños, Green Peppers, Banana Peppers, Tomatoes
  $1.00
Seafood
- Fried Jumbo Shrimp
  6 fantail shrimp, deep fried to perfection served with cocktail sauce.
  $16.00
- Seafood Shrimp Platter
  Breaded fantail shrimp, popcorn shrimp, shrimp scampi, hand breaded oysters.
  $19.00
- Deep Fried Oysters
  A dinner of hand breaded, fresh oysters! Served with our cocktail sauce.
  $15.00
- Grilled Shrimp Skewers
  Two grilled skewers scampi or Cajun style served with drawn butter.
  $14.00
- Fried Haddock Fillet
  Nothern Atlantic Haddock, deep fried and served with our tartar sauce.
  $12.00
All Dinners include Your Choice of Two Sides
- Baked Potato
- Homemade Cole Slaw
- Cottage Cheese
- French Fries
- Green Beans
- Grilled Mushrooms
- Grilled Onions
- Onion Rings
- House Salad With Tomatoes & Croutons
  $1.00
- Homemade Hash Browns
Our Homemade Dressings
- Italian (House Special)
- French
- Ranch
- Blue Cheese
- Honey Mustard
- Thousand Island
Beverages
- Pepsi
  $3.00
- Diet Pepsi
  $3.00
- Mountain Dew
  $3.00
- Sierra Mist
  $3.00
- Dr. Pepper
  $3.00
- Fresh Brewed Iced Tea
  $3.00
- Hot Tea
  $3.00
Beer
- Budweiser
- Bud Light
- Coors Light
- Michelob Ultra
- Miller Lite
- Yuengling
- Yuengling Lite
- Yuengling Black & Tan
- Sam Adams Seasonal
- Blue Moon
Wine
- Barefoot
- Cabernet
- Merlot
- Chardonnay
- Moscato
- White Zinfandel
- Meijer’s Blackberry Wine
Appetizers
- Chilled Shrimp Cocktail
  $5.00
- Breaded Chicken Tenders
  $8.00
- Basket Of 21 Shrimp
  $10.00
- Basket Of Onion Rings
  $9.00
- Loaded Potato Skins
  $8.00
- Cheese Sticks
  $7.00
- Basket Of Oysters
  $12.00
- Basket Of French Fries
  $7.00
Just For Kids
- Cheeseburger & Fries
  $6.00
- Chicken Tenders & Fries
  $6.00
- Fried Shrimp & Fries
  $7.00
- Sirloin Steak & Fries
  $8.00
Sandwiches
- Castaways Special
  $7.00
- Classic Club Sandwich
  $7.00
- Grilled Sausage Sandwich
  $6.00
- Fish Filet Sandwich
  $6.00
- Grilled Chicken Sandwich
  $8.00
- Mushroom, Onion & Swiss Burger
  $7.00
- Oyster Sandwich
  $6.00
Sides
- Baked Potato
  $3.00
- Homemade Cole Slaw
  $3.00
- Cottage Cheese
  $3.00
- French Fries
  $3.00
- Green Beans
  $3.00
- Grilled Mushrooms
  $3.00
- Grilled Onions
  $3.00
- Onion Rings
  $3.00
- House Salad
  $3.00
- Hash Browns
  $3.00
Dinner Salads
- Steak Salad
  $10.00
- Grilled Chicken Salad
  $10.00
- Shrimp Salad
  $9.00
- Chef Salad
  $9.00
Homemade Dressings
- Italian
- Ranch
- Blue Cheese
- French
- Thousand Island
- Honey Mustard
Main Fare
- Sirloin Steak For Two
  $31.00
- Sirloin Steak For One
  $17.00
- Porterhouse Steak
  $22.00
- New York Strip Steak
  $22.00
- 10oz Filet
  $23.00
- 8oz Filet
  $23.00
- Boneless Ribeye Steak
  $22.00
- Sirloin Steak And Shrimp
  $22.00
- Surf & Turf
  $36.00
- Ground Round Steak
  $11.00
- Boneless Pork Tenderloin
  $10.00
- Center Cut Ham Steak
  $11.00
- Deluxe Chicken Breast
  $13.00
- Grilled Chicken Breast
  $12.00
- Chicken Tenders
  $10.00
Seafood
- Fried Jumbo Shrimp
  $14.00
- Deep Fried Oysters
  $12.00
- Twin Rock Lobster Tails
  $36.00
- Seafood Shrimp Platter
  $17.00
- Grilled Shrimp Skewers
  $12.00
- Fried Haddock Filet
  $10.00
12 inch Stone Baked Pizza
- Cheese Pizza
  $10.00
- Pepperoni Pizza
  $11.00
- Works Pizza
  $14.00
- All The Way Meat Pizza
  $17.00
- All The Way Veggie Pizza
  $17.00
Beer
- Budweiser
- Bud Light
- Coors Light
- Michelob Ultra
- Miller Lite
- Yuengling
- Yuengling Lite
- Yuengling Black & Tan
- Sam Adams Seasonal
- Blue Moon
Wine
- Barefoot
- Cabernet
- Merlot
- Chardonnay
- Moscato
- White Zinfandel
- Meijer’s Blackberry Wine

Menu Gallery

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

Privacy

Terms

Appetizers
- Chilled Shrimp Cocktail
  A classic favorite! 6 Jumbo Shrimp served with cocktail sauce.
  $6.00
- Loaded Potato Skins
  6 skins stuffed with provolone cheese, bacon, and scallions, with sour cream.
  $10.00
- Breaded Chicken Tenders
  6 white meat tenders served with ranch, BBQ, honey mustard.
  $10.00
- Cheese Sticks
  6 breaded cheese sticks, deep fried to perfection! Served with pizza sauce.
  $8.00
- Basket Of 21 Shrimp
  Fried golden brown and served with cocktail sauce.
  $11.00
- Basket Of Oysters
  Hand breaded, fresh oysters! Served with cocktail sauce.
  $15.00
- Basket Of Onion Rings
  A generous portion of our jumbo onion rings served with ranch dressing.
  $11.00
- Basket Of Fries
  Deep fried to a golden brown. More than enough to share!
  $10.00
Dinner Salads
- Chef's Salad
  A large garden salad topped with ham, turkey, Swiss cheese, egg, tomatoes, and croutons.
  $12.00
- Shrimp Salad
  A large garden salad topped with shrimp, Swiss cheese, egg, tomatoes, and croutons.
  $12.00
- Grilled Chicken Salad
  A large garden salad topped with chicken, bacon, egg, tomatoes, and croutons.
  $13.00
- Steak Salad
  A large garden topped with beef tenderloin, scallions, tomatoes, croutons.
  $14.00
Just For Kids
- Cheeseburger & Fries
  $8.00
- Chicken Tenders & Fries
  $6.00
- Fried Shrimp & Fries
  $9.00
- Sirloin Steak & Fries
  $10.00
Main Fare
- House Special* Sirloin Steak For Two
  It's what we are famous for! Choice cuts of mouthwatering Sirloin Steak served family style.
  $36.00
- Sirloin Steak For 3 Or More
  $19.00
- Sirloin Steak For One
  $22.00
- Porterhouse Steak
  The Great Steak Lovers Choice! A 16 oz cut, grilled to your liking.
  $28.00
- Y. Strip Steak
  A generous 16 oz boneless cut grilled to your liking.
  $28.00
- 10 Oz Filet Mignon
  A huge 10 oz cut smothered with mushrooms. The Best!
  $30.00
- 8 Oz Filet Mignon
  An 8 oz Filet served with a skewer of shrimp scampi.
  $30.00
- Sirloin Steak And Shrimp
  8 ounces of Sirloin and 3 fried jumbo shrimp. Served with cocktail sauce.
  $27.00
- Boneless Ribeye Steak
  A 16 oz hearty cut.
  $28.00
- Ground Round Steak
  An 8 oz patty of freshly ground round. Smothered with grilled onions.
  $13.00
- Boneless Pork Tenderloin
  Two juicy center cut chops, grilled just right.
  $12.00
- Center Cut Ham Steak
  A generous slice of Bay's smoked whole ham.
  $13.00
- Deluxe Chicken
  A 6 oz boneless breast topped with Swiss cheese, mushrooms, and bacon.
  $15.00
- Grilled Chicken Breast
  A deliciously seasoned 6 oz boneless breast seared to a golden brown.
  $14.00
- Breaded Chicken Tenders
  4 white meat tenders served with your choice of ranch, BBQ, or honey mustard.
  $12.00
Sandwiches
- Castaways Specials
  An American favorite! A big burger topped with cheese, lettuce, tomato, & onion.
  $9.00
- Chicken Sandwich
  Boneless all white meat chicken topped with lettuce, tomato, & onion.
  $10.00
- Grilled Sausage Sandwich
  A 1/4 pound patty of original sausage from Bay Food Market. Served with a slice of onion.
  $8.00
- Mushroom, Onion & Swiss
  A burger topped with grilled mushrooms, onions and Swiss cheese.
  $10.00
- Fish Fillet Sandwich
  North Atlantic Haddock served with our own tartar sauce.
  $7.00
- Oyster Sandwich
  Hand breaded, fresh oysters served with our own tartar or cocktail sauce.
  $8.00
Our Signature 12" Stone Baked Pizzas!
- Cheese Pizza
  $12.00
- Pepperoni Pizza
  $13.00
- Works Pizza
  Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Onions, Green Peppers or Banana Peppers.
  $16.00
Create Your Own Pizza
- Meat Toppings
  Pepperoni, Ham, Sausage, Hamburger, & Bacon.
  $2.00
- Veggie Toppings
  Mushrooms, Onions, Black Olives, Green Olives, Jalapeños, Green Peppers, Banana Peppers, Tomatoes
  $1.00
Seafood
- Fried Jumbo Shrimp
  6 fantail shrimp, deep fried to perfection served with cocktail sauce.
  $16.00
- Seafood Shrimp Platter
  Breaded fantail shrimp, popcorn shrimp, shrimp scampi, hand breaded oysters.
  $19.00
- Deep Fried Oysters
  A dinner of hand breaded, fresh oysters! Served with our cocktail sauce.
  $15.00
- Grilled Shrimp Skewers
  Two grilled skewers scampi or Cajun style served with drawn butter.
  $14.00
- Fried Haddock Fillet
  Nothern Atlantic Haddock, deep fried and served with our tartar sauce.
  $12.00
All Dinners include Your Choice of Two Sides
- Baked Potato
- Homemade Cole Slaw
- Cottage Cheese
- French Fries
- Green Beans
- Grilled Mushrooms
- Grilled Onions
- Onion Rings
- House Salad With Tomatoes & Croutons
  $1.00
- Homemade Hash Browns
Our Homemade Dressings
- Italian (House Special)
- French
- Ranch
- Blue Cheese
- Honey Mustard
- Thousand Island
Beverages
- Pepsi
  $3.00
- Diet Pepsi
  $3.00
- Mountain Dew
  $3.00
- Sierra Mist
  $3.00
- Dr. Pepper
  $3.00
- Fresh Brewed Iced Tea
  $3.00
- Hot Tea
  $3.00
Beer
- Budweiser
- Bud Light
- Coors Light
- Michelob Ultra
- Miller Lite
- Yuengling
- Yuengling Lite
- Yuengling Black & Tan
- Sam Adams Seasonal
- Blue Moon
Wine
- Barefoot
- Cabernet
- Merlot
- Chardonnay
- Moscato
- White Zinfandel
- Meijer’s Blackberry Wine
Appetizers
- Chilled Shrimp Cocktail
  $5.00
- Breaded Chicken Tenders
  $8.00
- Basket Of 21 Shrimp
  $10.00
- Basket Of Onion Rings
  $9.00
- Loaded Potato Skins
  $8.00
- Cheese Sticks
  $7.00
- Basket Of Oysters
  $12.00
- Basket Of French Fries
  $7.00
Just For Kids
- Cheeseburger & Fries
  $6.00
- Chicken Tenders & Fries
  $6.00
- Fried Shrimp & Fries
  $7.00
- Sirloin Steak & Fries
  $8.00
Sandwiches
- Castaways Special
  $7.00
- Classic Club Sandwich
  $7.00
- Grilled Sausage Sandwich
  $6.00
- Fish Filet Sandwich
  $6.00
- Grilled Chicken Sandwich
  $8.00
- Mushroom, Onion & Swiss Burger
  $7.00
- Oyster Sandwich
  $6.00
Sides
- Baked Potato
  $3.00
- Homemade Cole Slaw
  $3.00
- Cottage Cheese
  $3.00
- French Fries
  $3.00
- Green Beans
  $3.00
- Grilled Mushrooms
  $3.00
- Grilled Onions
  $3.00
- Onion Rings
  $3.00
- House Salad
  $3.00
- Hash Browns
  $3.00
Dinner Salads
- Steak Salad
  $10.00
- Grilled Chicken Salad
  $10.00
- Shrimp Salad
  $9.00
- Chef Salad
  $9.00
Homemade Dressings
- Italian
- Ranch
- Blue Cheese
- French
- Thousand Island
- Honey Mustard
Main Fare
- Sirloin Steak For Two
  $31.00
- Sirloin Steak For One
  $17.00
- Porterhouse Steak
  $22.00
- New York Strip Steak
  $22.00
- 10oz Filet
  $23.00
- 8oz Filet
  $23.00
- Boneless Ribeye Steak
  $22.00
- Sirloin Steak And Shrimp
  $22.00
- Surf & Turf
  $36.00
- Ground Round Steak
  $11.00
- Boneless Pork Tenderloin
  $10.00
- Center Cut Ham Steak
  $11.00
- Deluxe Chicken Breast
  $13.00
- Grilled Chicken Breast
  $12.00
- Chicken Tenders
  $10.00
Seafood
- Fried Jumbo Shrimp
  $14.00
- Deep Fried Oysters
  $12.00
- Twin Rock Lobster Tails
  $36.00
- Seafood Shrimp Platter
  $17.00
- Grilled Shrimp Skewers
  $12.00
- Fried Haddock Filet
  $10.00
12 inch Stone Baked Pizza
- Cheese Pizza
  $10.00
- Pepperoni Pizza
  $11.00
- Works Pizza
  $14.00
- All The Way Meat Pizza
  $17.00
- All The Way Veggie Pizza
  $17.00
Beer
- Budweiser
- Bud Light
- Coors Light
- Michelob Ultra
- Miller Lite
- Yuengling
- Yuengling Lite
- Yuengling Black & Tan
- Sam Adams Seasonal
- Blue Moon
Wine
- Barefoot
- Cabernet
- Merlot
- Chardonnay
- Moscato
- White Zinfandel
- Meijer’s Blackberry Wine

Castaways Menu

Appetizers

Chilled Shrimp Cocktail

Loaded Potato Skins

Breaded Chicken Tenders

Cheese Sticks

Basket Of 21 Shrimp

Basket Of Oysters

Basket Of Onion Rings

Basket Of Fries

Dinner Salads

Chef's Salad

Shrimp Salad

Grilled Chicken Salad

Steak Salad

Just For Kids

Cheeseburger & Fries

Chicken Tenders & Fries

Fried Shrimp & Fries

Sirloin Steak & Fries

Main Fare

House Special* Sirloin Steak For Two

Sirloin Steak For 3 Or More

Sirloin Steak For One

Porterhouse Steak

Y. Strip Steak

10 Oz Filet Mignon

8 Oz Filet Mignon

Sirloin Steak And Shrimp

Boneless Ribeye Steak

Ground Round Steak

Boneless Pork Tenderloin

Center Cut Ham Steak

Deluxe Chicken

Grilled Chicken Breast

Breaded Chicken Tenders

Sandwiches

Castaways Specials

Chicken Sandwich

Grilled Sausage Sandwich

Mushroom, Onion & Swiss

Fish Fillet Sandwich

Oyster Sandwich

Our Signature 12" Stone Baked Pizzas!

Cheese Pizza

Pepperoni Pizza

Works Pizza

Create Your Own Pizza

Meat Toppings

Veggie Toppings

Seafood

Fried Jumbo Shrimp

Seafood Shrimp Platter

Deep Fried Oysters

Grilled Shrimp Skewers

Fried Haddock Fillet

All Dinners include Your Choice of Two Sides

Baked Potato

Homemade Cole Slaw

Cottage Cheese

French Fries

Green Beans

Grilled Mushrooms

Grilled Onions

Onion Rings

House Salad With Tomatoes & Croutons

Homemade Hash Browns

Our Homemade Dressings

Italian (House Special)

French

Ranch

Blue Cheese

Honey Mustard

Thousand Island

Beverages

Pepsi

Diet Pepsi

Mountain Dew

Sierra Mist

Dr. Pepper