Overrated and a bit Expensive. I tried the key lime pie on a stick from the Sarasota Farmers Market because I saw many people eating them. Satisfactory but I was expecting it to be better based on the $6 price tag!! Here’s why - I thought because it was frozen treat that the key lime pie itself would have the cold frozen popsicle style, needing a good bite but instead it seemed and tasted room temperature with just layer of frozen chocolate.
Best Key Lime Pie, we always get a pie when visiting Sarasota
Key Lime Pie is really good and their pie on a stick is really good.
The best key lime pie I've ever had !
Key Lime Pie was delicious
While in Sarasota, we decided to get some key lime pies as it is my favorite dessert, but we had to leave the next day. First off when we entered, the owner was super nice and welcoming to us! We decided to get the regular and tropical key lime pies and brought it back with us 11 hours home (put in a cooler in the car). It was still good, and we tried the pies which were super delicious. We gave our neighbor some of the pie we had, and they finished it within the same day we gave them the key lime pie. We and our neighbors think this is the best key lime pie we have ever had. Honestly, we regret buying two pies, we should have bought more!