Cape May Cafe

I loved this seafood buffet! Delicious!!!

Providing character breakfasts including Minnie, Goofy, Donald, and Daisy as well as seafood buffets at lunch and dinner. Located in the Beach Club Resort.

Blown away by the level of service for an allergy kid at Cape May's dinner service. Chef Rene went above and beyond. My tree nut, wheat, and egg allergy kid ate like a king tonight. Way more food then a 7 year old could possibly eat and they let him box up the leftovers. After the meal, he brought several other chefs out to meet my son and even had a signed menu for him with a Chef TJ sticker. Definitely recommend if you can get a reservation. Dietary restrictions: We manage tree nut, wheat, and egg allergies and are not safe with cross contamination so the kitchen had my son mark up the allergy menu with what he wanted and delivered him multiple courses from the back over the course of the meal. The portions were all large and he never felt like he was missing out on the buffet experience. The food was fantastic particularly the special dessert they brought out for him. Truly a magical experience.

This used to be my most favorite place to dine in all of WDW resorts. Not sure what happened, I suppose it will be blamed on Covid, but whew. No longer a favorite. Spent a recent Tuesday evening there for dinner and was actually shocked at how much had changed since the last (several years) visit. The selection was diminished, but more than that, what was there did not taste good. The clams were odd, not briny rather muddy in taste. The mussels were in a mishmash of tomato and onion? maybe? Skipped them all together. The non-seafood side had dismal looking choices (and the taste matched). Service was mediocre with the server bringing the check without being asked 30 minutes into our meal. No, they were not busy (a tell tale sign). The desserts were pitiful. Selection was nothing compared to what it used to be. So, we'll not return any time soon.

We had the most amazing dinner here. Service was amazing, our waiter Scott was the best we have had at any Disney property. Food was amazing and everything was fantastic.