Cafe Fifth Ave

Great staff and ownership. Details matter. I thank them for lending a hand!

Went here before a concert. They were packed but everyone had a drink in their hand. Great service.

First time at Café Fifth Ave for food and drinks before Penguins game. We got there at 1:16pm the place wasn’t to packed and our server Clara was phenomenal. She did an amazing job sending our food order to kitchen and checking on us every 8-14mins. I ordered Italian hoagie and it was delicious. Overall • Bathroom upstairs 3.5 stars • Food was 4 stars • Severs 5 stars due to short staffing they were really hustling. Thanks again!

Food was bar’ish. Apparently there are 2 kitchens on the premises, or at least is what we were told, so depending on what you order, the food will arrive at different times. Half of the people at our table finished eating while the other half was still waiting on their food. Beer was good, it’s hard to mess that up.

Waitress thought we were from out of town for the Penguins game. We paid cash. She left then came back 10 minutes later claiming we never tipped her and that we were causing issues. We literally bought an old couple shots and ordered $100 in alcohol. Don’t pay cash they are sooo shady. Waitress was ghetto AF. Avoid this place. Edit: not embarrassing for me. Gave you guys over a $150 of my money. Your waitress waited till we were leaving like a coward to “confront us” about a tip. She could have been professional and just quietly asked us about any confusion on the bill because we paid her and were seated for 15minutes after she had our money. Why not say anything then ? Why loudly claim no tip and cause a scene?Why did she try to give us back our money and demand a card payment? That would even cover the bill lol. Maybe pay your waitress a livable wage so they aren’t aggressively harassing customers. Why did you (the owner) not try to talk to us. Instead you avoid eye contact and went to a corner and hid? Problematic claim also was funny. Buying folks around us shots is being a problem? You and your waitress are embarrassing.