Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Murfreesboro

I tried the Key Lime cookie and wasn't impressed. Although the key lime filling is good, the actual cookie batter is too doughy and very bland tasting. Not worth $1 for such a small bite size cookie.

OMG..... This is absolutely what cheat days are made of! The staff was super friendly when I visited for the first time. The selection was great and they tasted even better than a look. Really fresh and ingredients, All the pies that we got lift a clean not overly sugary taste and we will definitely be going back.

The pies are utterly delicious!

Don't expect them to honor the coupons they email out. No benefit to giving them your personal information other than data mining

I received a coupon for a free pie on my birthday as I do every year but when I went to use it the person working said they weren’t honoring them because they couldn’t afford it. Then why send it? I’m the future when faced with where to go get dessert who do you think I’ll choose? The cake place who gave me a free cake and wished me happy birthday with a smile OR the pie place that sent me a coupon but refused to honor it. I tried to contact the business first before leaving a review but got no response.

Stopped in to see what it's all about and ended up with 4 small pies for $19 (+tax). The place was clean, the staff was friendly, and the price was reasonable to me. The packaging is a lot. It's in an aluminum tin that's suspended in essentially a bubble of plastic. If you follow me, you know I try to avoid that type of thing, but I get it. They're to protect the pie. We got 1 pumpkin, 1 peanut butter chocolate, 1 chocolate cream, and 1 buttermilk. My partner loved his PB one. The chocolate cream was really good with a chocolate crust The pumpkin was lackluster to me. No punch of pumpkin; the crust and little sugary pumpkin on top overwhelmed the filling flavor. We haven't had the buttermilk yet, but it has the same crust as the pumpkin, so I am assuming it'll be similar. In sum: I liked it, but not enough to seek it out again and risk the barley for it. If you like sugar cookie style crust, though, this is your place!

Every pie I’ve tried here is delicious! As someone who is usually in a hurry, this place is my go to stop to get pies before family events! They are always a hit

Nice people but not my idea of a quality product. I know that reviews are totally subjective, but this is my experience. The coconut cream pie was cloyingly sweet, too heavy-handed use of coconut extract and the crust was basically a butter cookie, not a pastry in the least. I was really hoping for a top notch pie bakery in Murfreesboro but this wasn't it.