Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

Buttermilk Sky Pies are the best PIES! Their signature pie crust alone is perfection! Great as gifts and for any celebration!

Pies are delicious……

These piese are soo tasty and fresh! We tried the small ones, in key lime pie and I-40 and I especially enjoyed the key lime pie, so refreshing and soft! Every small pie was priced 5.25 and for what they offer it s a fair price for sure! I will go to them every time I m craving pie!

Had the new turtle pie for a work gathering, and was very disappointed. Coworkers took a bite or two and threw theirs in the trash. It was gritty, you almost need an axe to cut the crust, and just overwhelmingly syrupy sweet. Got a four pack of the mini pies as well, and so far have only tried the coconut. Unfortunately it was 75% gritty meringue and about 25% coconut filling. 28.00 is a staggering price to pay for a pie that chokes you going down unless you have a ton of water to drink. I was hoping for a much better experience after hearing all the false hype.

Good service, good pie.

Some of the best pie crust we have had in years. Great pies cute shop. Good selection. Not much seating tho