Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Greenville

Kind staff and delicious pies.

We were excited to try this pie shop based upon reviews. The pies are very expensive at $35 plus they ask for a tip, which I don’t mind if they are good. We got the banana cream pie and it was way too sweet. There were also no sliced bananas just a heavy sweet filling. I had a very small piece and could not finish it because of the sweetness. Disappointed that a $35 dollar pie is not edible.

Total yum!!!

3hour drive…closed. Not advertised hours. Figures.

This pie shop gas it all, Great Pie, Excellent Service, and a Quaint Atmosphere. I Order thru the website and everything is Always ready on time.

Awesome selections of pies and cookies. Very friendly workers. Thank you for helping me make my husband's birthday wonderful!

Absolutely the best pies around.

Wow! These pies are truly awesome, and the service is the icing on the cake. Er, the icing on the PIE. We arrived a few moments after they closed, and my wife commented that we’d just have to wait in the parking lot until they open the next morning. We didn’t have to wait long, the lady waved us in so we could make a couple of quick purchases before continuing on our long journey. Such awesome customer service, combined with delicious pies, makes this place truly special!