Butterfly Café

Lovely, great food, just be aware this is fine dining with a price tag to mat h

The perfect meal! The yellow snapper was perfect. The key lime martini was amazing. The service was awesome. The place was charming and clean. I would return to the keys just to eat this meal again! Vegetarian options: I saw quite a few delicious looking vegetarian options on the menu.

We were staying at the property and went to have dinner there. The host is really rude and has a butt face, gave us attitude when we asked to sit away from the fans, that were on when the weather was chilly and windy. The food is not worth its price, I could have made a better scallop risotto for $54. Our waitress was really nice though.

Celebrated hubby's birthday. We had a lovely time. Service and atmosphere were great.

Lovely space and the food is very good. Service was good except for a few small hiccups. There were 4 of us and we ordered a bottle of Prosecco for my husband and me plus our older son (22). He sometimes gets carded in nice restaurants so that wasn’t off putting at all. After the server examined it and we thought she would hand it back, she said “just a minute” and left with my son’s license without explanation nor asking if that was ok. After about 5 minutes, we became concerned so I got up to try to find her. It took the staff a few more minutes to locate her and she seemed annoyed that I wanted the license back. No apology. The food service was good and we would have tipped her well after that was resolved but she pre added 18% (I guess because she worried we wouldn’t tip) so I just left it at that. We would go back and just not order drinks to avoid issues.

Very cozy and the food was delicious! The lemon pie was golden medal. This restaurant is inside Tranquility Bay Resort, with options to dine inside or outside. Dietary restrictions: They were good managing allergy requests.

Fantastic food!

Good