Brooklyn Water Bagel

(Pescatarian Reviewer) This place is pretty good. I had an everything bagel with avocado and smoked salmon and really enjoyed it!

It's Sunday morning just drove 40 minutes to get some bagels, I walk in the store and you're out of bagels. Won't be making that mistake again

I got Jersey bagel which is egg sandwich with pork roll(Taylor ham). I was terribly disappointed the slice of pork roll on the sandwich was so thin you could see through it

We really do think the food is good here but when it comes to getting the order right that’s a different story! The staff working the front of the house is great but the people in the back just don’t seem to get the orders right especially online orders. My husband and I made an online order where they completely just didn’t make his order even close to correct. He ordered the Leo which is supposed to have salmon and is $11.50. He literally just got a bagel with cream cheese and onion. That is it. This isn’t our only experience having a wrong order. I’ve ordered tuna fish salad sandwiches, where they have given my chicken salad and gave me also a melt once which I didn’t ask for. I really do want to like this place because when the order is right it’s really good but I can’t get myself to give a higher review because about half my orders have been made wrong.