Bizzarro of Bayside Lakes

Our family had a large delivery order for over 30 people for a funeral service at our home. We ordered Chicken Parmesan, Chicken Marsala, Ziti, Caesar Salad and Garlic Knots. The price was right, the delivery was smooth and the food was delicious. Thank you for the great food and service.

pizzas chill

Nice place to eat pizza is great food prices are reasonable.

Great pizza and great service.

Food came out loaded with cheese that was barely cooked. Very upsetting, waited a whole hour at the shop and it came out cold and wasn’t good at all

False advertising. I’ve repeatedly tried to order Sicilian pizza, which is listed on THEIR MENU. I get a call telling me they are “out”. They had the audacity to call me to cancel and resubmit my Slice order. Girl could not form a complete thought or provide any alternatives. I took my business elsewhere. Their pizza isn’t worth the trouble I promise.

Ordered a Stromboli and the bottom was burnt

Ordered the $30.99 deal for delivery on the Slice app. When the pizza arrive an hour and a half later, it was cold, greasy and the crust tasted like cardboard, the wings were tasteless and the calamari was soft. The only thing that was decent were the garlic knots. My daughter warned me that this location wasn’t good. Won’t make that mistake again.

Save yourself the hassle and just don't order from here. Every time we order delivery there's an insane wait time but this last time we waited 3 1/2 hours for a pizza and a salad. We called twice, first time was after 1 1/2 hours and they said it was on the way. The 2nd time we called (an hour after the first phone call, so 2 1/2 hours after we placed the order)the lady said there was a mess up and the delivery guy forgot our order. I was understanding and tried to be chill about it since she was trying to make it right with some extra food and what not. The food arrived an hour later, cold, wrong pizza, soggy croutons, and no extras. Seriously disappointed in this store since bizarros has been a long time favorite of mine but I refuse to spend $55 bucks on food that's not right and arrives almost 4 HOURS after ordering.