Search
Benchwarmer Pizza & Subs Menu
4.2
(75+ Reviews)
SMALL Cold Subs
- B.L.T Sub - SmallBacon, Lettuce, and Tomatoes$8.95
- Cold Veggies Sub - SmallComes with lettuce, tomato, pickles, onions and bell peppers$8.95
- Italian Sub - SmallMortadella, provolone, and salami$8.95
- Onion RingSliced Thin$8.95
- Ham & Cheese Sub - Small$8.95
- Chicken Salad Sub - Small$8.95
- Tuna Sub - Smallmixed with a small amount of mayo$9.95
- Benchwarmer Club Sub - SmallBLT with ham, turkey, and American cheese$11.45
- Cranberry Walnut Chix Salad Sub$8.95
LARGE Cold Subs
- Cold Veggies Sub - LargeComes with lettuce, tomato, pickles, onions, cucumbers, peppers, and hots.$10.95
- Italian Sub - LargeMortadella, provolone, and salami with lettuce, tomatoes, pickles, onions, olive oil, and hot pepper spread.$10.95
- BLT Sub - Large$10.95
- GC- Beaver Dam$5.00
- Ham & Cheese Sub - Large$10.95
- Chicken Salad Sub - Large$11.95
- Tuna Sub - Largemixed with a light amount of mayo$11.95
- Benchwarmer Club Sub - LargeBLT with ham, turkey, and American cheese$13.95
SMALL Hot Subs
- Hamburger Sub - Smallserved plain... just tell us how you like it!$8.95
- Cheeseburger Sub - Smallserved plain.. just tell us how you like it!$9.95
- Hot Vegetarian Sub - Smallgrilled mushrooms, peppers, onions, and provolone cheese$8.95
- Chicken Stir Fry Sub - Smallgrilled chicken, mushrooms, peppers, onions, and provolone cheese$9.95
- Chicken Cutlet Sub - Smallbreaded and fried chicken cutlets served plain... just tell us how you like it!$9.95
- Chicken Parm Sub - Smallbreaded chicken, provolone cheese, and marinara$9.95
- Buffalo Chicken Sub - Smallbreaded buffalo chicken cutlets served plain...just tell us how you like it!$9.95
- BBQ Chicken Sub - Smallbreaded BBQ chicken cutlets served plain...just tell us how you like it!$9.95
- Eggplant Sub - Smallbreaded eggplant rounds with provolone cheese and marinara$9.95
- Meatball Sub - Smallhomestyle meatballs with provolone cheese and marinara$9.95
- Steak & Cheese Sub - Small$9.95
- Pastrami Sub - Smallshaved pastrami$9.95
- Grand Slam Sub - Smallshaved steak, grilled mushrooms, peppers, onions, and american cheese$9.95
- Pastrami & Egg Sub - Small$9.95
- Pepper & Egg Sub - Small$9.95
- Western Sub - Smallscrambled eggs, grilled ham, peppers, onions, and provolone cheese$9.95
- Nasty Errasti Sub - Smallcheeseburger chopped up with grilled mushrooms, peppers, and onions with lettuce, tomato, hot peppers, ketchup, mayo, and mustard$9.95
LARGE Hot Subs
- Hamburger Sub - Largeserved plain...just tell us how you like it!$10.95
- Cheeseburger Sub - Largeserved plain...just tell us how you like it!$11.95
- Hot Vegetarian Sub - Largegrilled mushrooms, peppers, onions, and provolone cheese$10.95
- Chicken Cutlet Sub - Largebreaded chicken cutlets served plain...just tell us how you like it!$11.95
- Chicken Parm Sub - Largebreaded chicken cutlets, provolone cheese, and marinara$11.95
- Buffalo Chicken Sub - LargeFried chicken cutlets dipped in Buffalo sauce$11.95
- BBQ Chicken Sub - Largebreaded BBQ chicken cutlets served plain..just tell us how you like it!$11.95
- Steak & Cheese Sub - Large$11.95
- Eggplant Sub - Largebreaded eggplant rounds with provolone cheese and marinara$11.95
- Meatball Sub - Largehomestyle meatballs with provolone cheese and marinara$11.95
- Nasty Errasti Sub - LargeCheeseburger chopped up with peppers, onions, and mushrooms with lettuce and tomato, hot peppers and ketchup, mayo, and mustard$11.95
- Pastrami Sub - LargeShaved Pastrami$11.95
- Grand Slam Sub - LargeShaved Steak, Grilled Peppers, Mushrooms and onions loaded with American Cheese$11.95
- Pastrami & Egg Sub - Large$11.95
- Pepper & Egg Sub - LargeGrilled peppers and egg, please let us know if you would like to add cheese!$11.95
- Western Sub - LargeScrambled Eggs, Ham, Peppers, Onions. Please let us know if you would like to add cheese!$11.95
Calzones
- Buffalo Chicken Calzone - SmallStuffed with buffalo chicken and mozzarella cheese$17.95
- Buffalo Chicken Calzone - LargeStuffed with buffalo chicken and mozzarella cheese$21.95
- Steak & Cheese Calzone - SmallStuffed with mozzarella and sliced steak.$15.95
- Steak & Cheese Calzone - LargeStuffed with mozzarella and sliced steak.$19.95
- Spinach, Tomato & Feta Calzone - Small$15.95
- Spinach, Tomato & Feta - Large$19.95
- Meat Lovers Calzone - Small$13.95
- Meat Lovers Calzone - Large$17.95
Quesadillas
- Veggie QuesadillaBlack olives, spinach, tomato, onion, feta, and mozzarella cheese on a spinach wrap$8.95
- Buffalo Chicken QuesadillaGrilled chicken with buffalo sauce, mozzarella cheese and a side of blue cheese or ranch dressing$11.95
Kids Menu & Side Orders
- French FriesShoe string fries$3.26
- Curly FriesSpiralized potatoes, deep-fried and seasoned.$4.20
- Mozzarella Sticks (6)$6.99
- Small Chips
- Large Chips$2.79
- Grilled Cheese$6.00
- Chicken Fingers (5)$7.95
- Onion Rings$4.50
- Chicken WingsHalf Dozen crispy fried wings$7.50
- Hot Dog$2.80
Beverages
- Pepsi
- Root Beer20 oz$2.66
- Mountain Dew
- Diet Pepsi2 Liter$3.79
- Sierra Mist20 oz$2.66
- LemonadeRegular 20 oz$2.66
- Orange Crush20 oz$2.66
- Ginger Ale20 oz$2.66
- Iced Tea$3.26
- Apple Juice$3.26
- Cranberry Juice$3.26
- Hornstra Chocolate Milk$3.26
- Water$2.00
Desserts
- Cookies$1.00
- Richie's Italian IceSeasonal Flavors$3.26
Pizza
- Small 14 Pizza$14.95
- X-Large 18 Pizza$17.85
- Cheese Slice PizzaCheese$3.50
- Pepperoni Slice Pizza$4.00
- Buffalo Slice Pizza$4.25
Salads
- Caesar SaladCrisp romaine tossed with croutons, Caesar dressing, and parmesan cheese$10.26
- Chef SaladTurkey, ham, salami, provolone, rolled and sliced over a fresh garden salad$13.52
- Greek SaladTomatoes, cucumbers, peppers, black olives, and feta cheese$12.00
- Italian Garden SaladMortadella, provolone, and salami rolled and sliced served over lettuce, tomatoes, and onions$13.50
- House SaladLettuce, tomatoes, peppers, and cucumbers with your choice of dressing.$10.26
Menu Photos
Menu Photos
Loading...
