Bella Mae's

Got fast and friendly delivery. The best pizza I’ve had in a while. Seems like it can be hit or miss based on other reviews but when it’s good it’s really really good. Worth a shot and always a second chance.

Ordered wings & garlic knots. Asked for crispy wings, definitely not. No flavor at all. 2 orders of wings got 4 pieces of carrot. Garlic knots no flavor, marinara sauce no flavor at all. Very disappointing. Won’t be going back.

This 'establishment' does not support Averill Park Sports Teams.

Great people and fantastic Pizza

I'm from Long Island, and the pizza there is epic and so much better than anywhere in the world. Bella Mae's pizza is THE best outside of that area! If you want something specific, they're so very accommodating. The garlic knots? Better than Long Island, NYC and anywhere.

They did it again. How many ways cant they screw up an order? I will never find out because I am done with them. Ordered a pizza online showed up on time was told they were closing .. asked about my pizza I had already ordered and paid for. They went "Oh yea.. where is that pizza ..." They found it in the oven where they had forgotten it. Offered to make another since i had already paid for it .. Sorry.. don't have the time to waste on their mistake. Thank you slice for refunding my money ... Never going back to Bella Maes again