Bay34th Street Pizzeria

Overall good experience for pizza by the slice, i was happy with the options. The food was good and service was attentive.

I used to be a regular customer years ago, when they first opened, and I lived right around the corner from them. This past weekend, I was craving their lasagna pizza. I was so happy when I googled them and saw that they were still open (it's been over 5 years since my last visit). I ordered my standard "go to" order - a medium lasagna pizza, a chicken and broccoli calzone and a large orange soda. My son and I devoured the lasagna pizza on the drive back to Plano. The staff was super friendly (as always). The food was fresh and delicious! Nothing has changed. I definitely won't be waiting another 5 years until my next visit! I love this place!

I’m a New Yorker and I highly recommend everyone to try this hidden gem. I finally found my go to NY Pizzeria style spot in Texas!

For my order all was so good and the pizza was delivered on time. My only concern was witnessing a Spanish speaking patron not feeling they could order when the menu had lots of pictures and no offer to help was given. They were going to walk out if I hadn't offered to translate. Do better. Everyone deserves the dignity to be served. Thank you.

Pizza was good, great crust, but the toppings were sparse.

My friends and I were craving some pizza and we didn’t want any chain pizza restaurants. The first place that popped up was Bay34th Street Pizzeria and we were IMPRESSED. We loved the pizza, the amazing service, and ambiance. We got a whole 18 inch half cheese half pepperoni pizza which fed 3 people pretty well. We also got a homemade cannoli which we would rate 8/10. There was a little too much powdered sugar for our taste, but if you love powdered sugar it is amazing! If you are looking for NY style pizza, come here :) You will not regret it!

I personally liked the vibe of the restaurant. I was treated really well. They gave great customer service. The pizza we got was pretty good. They could have added more sauce, but they may have just been a personal preference. I would eat here again and recommend people to give it a try!