Bay House Oyster Bar & Restaurant

One of the best restaurants in Erie. I read some comments that they are over-priced, but I don’t think so. You get what you pay for. Both food and drinks, service, and the atmosphere were perfect.

Fancy, but not over the top. Accommodating, we just showed up, and they worked to help us get seated.

Great food, great service, great view

Delicious food with beautiful presentation, good selection of drinks, great service and beautiful interior. Though, you pay a premium food price for it being the upscale place by the bayfront. Would still go back for special occasions.

We visited twice during our stay in Erie. It is expensive but they really care about their food here. First stop, we just had oysters and a drink. Service was poor. Our next visit was for dinner. Much better service and the food was excellent. The side of lobster Mac n cheese is huge. Silky smooth cheese sauce with truffle. Beautiful pasta and just cooked lobster. The fillet mignon is expensive but highly recommended. The brandy peppercorn sauce was over seasoned.

The food, drinks and hospitality are top notch!

Service was so slow it took almost 30 minutes to get drinks and I eventually had to ask for our soups when we were finished with our dinner. I’m pretty sure they totally forgot about us even being there. A hostess had to take our order when no one else showed up to our table. They were out of MANY things and seemed unprepared for the amount of people the eclipse brought in. They were sold out of the soup we wanted and about half of the types of oysters listed on their menu. The food and drinks that we did eventually receive were good but I’d definitely look for somewhere else next time.