Ratings of Bagelheads

google
Google
4.0
(722 Reviews)
yelp
Yelp
3.6
(339 Reviews)
tripadvisor
TripAdvisor
4.5
(197 Reviews)

Happy Hours & Specials

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?


Photos

  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo
  • Business Photo

Location & Hours

Buzzing, counter-serve outpost offering sandwiches, soups & bagels, plus an espresso bar & desserts.

916 E Gregory St
Pensacola, FL 32502
Monday
7:00 AM - 2:00 PM
Tuesday
7:00 AM - 2:00 PM
Wednesday
7:00 AM - 2:00 PM
Thursday
7:00 AM - 2:00 PM
Friday
7:00 AM - 2:00 PM
Saturday
7:00 AM - 2:00 PM
Sunday
7:00 AM - 2:00 PM

Recent Reviews

google
Mar 2024
Breakfast sandwich = A+++ Coffee = A+++ Chocolate muffin = A+++
google
Mar 2024
Bagelheads was a go-to spot for me in college, and I was thrilled to be able to come back on a visit for vacation! The negative reviews had me worried that this would not be the spot I remembered, however I am so pleased that it held up to my memories. The renovation has the place looking beautiful, but didn't take away the charm and vibes that I remember. My bagel was exactly as I remember, and my order hasn't changed since college, Blueberry Cobbler with strawberry cream cheese. The staff I interacted with and observed were perfectly lovely and welcoming. As I remember, this is a beautiful spot to get some sun, work on projects, and enjoy!
google
Mar 2024
I did not receive most of the items on my order
google
Mar 2024
I'm uncertain if they're understaffed, but the tables and floor weren't clean. I visited after 1pm on a Sunday. Additionally, there was an excessive amount of salt on the eggs.
google
Mar 2024
Staff is extremely rude. First time here and had a terrible experience with the staff. Requested a knife to spread my schmear and got eye rolling in response. Place had only 2 people in it and I can see why. No one wants to return to an establishment where they are treated so rudely by staff. Can’t even enjoy my bagel sandwich and move past the negative attitude because we can hear them swearing and talking about us.
google
Mar 2024
We stopped by Bagelheads for a late breakfast indulgence. The staff were all in a good mood, cleaning and singing along to their in-house music but noticed us quickly and took our order promptly, even suggesting some cream cheese pairings for our bagels when we asked. The bagel sandwich and toasted bagel were tasty, though the cream cheese here is a bit runnier than we were used to (but that’s probably a matter of preference). We took the food outdoors and it was a beautiful scenic view to drink in. The staff then boxes up the leftovers we brought in with a smile. Overall delightful spot with a very friendly atmosphere and bagels that don’t disappoint!
google
Feb 2024
***Edit in reply to owner’s comment on this review. Yes you might be using the same recipe, flavor is still there. However the way you prepare them is different as texture is 100% different. I know for a fact you are no longer steam proofing them, but are boiling them instead. I like a good boiled New York Bagel. Your bagels don’t even have the same texture as a NY bagel. It’s like they have been sitting out all day and have gotten stale. Plus in regards to I don’t like your vibe. I never said anything about your vibe or how the restaurant now looks. What I did say is the service aspect is gone and it 100% is. I used to love coming in here and the girls would bring me my food, we would chat and it was a personal-able experience. That is gone!! Now I go in and I’m completely ignored. I went in one time and the employees were all gathered together and ignoring customers. I felt like I was bothering them just to order my food. If that’s your vibe, the vibe of lack of customer service, then you can keep it. I’m done. I have been a longtime customer of Bagelheads and have always enjoyed everything on the menu. Since the renovation, the bagels have not been same. They are dry and almost stale like. The service aspect is gone as well. I have given this place several tries, thinking maybe they are just having an off day, but every time has been consistently bad. This is definitely not the same restaurant Rob had started and perfected. It’s now something completely different and not worth going to anymore.
google
Feb 2024
The potato salad is delicious! The ingredients are always so fresh. This place always brightens up my day.
google
Feb 2024
Place is awesome. The new renovations give the place a clean and beachy vibe which goes great with a delicious bagel sandwich. You also can’t beat the view of the bay while there. I always get the lox works on an everything bagel. Also as a person who’s been coming to bagel heads for the last 10 years, I will say the staff is 100x more pleasant and actually smiles when they take your order.
google
Feb 2024
Bagelheads is a delightful spot for a breakfast or brunch indulgence. While the wait may test your patience, the delicious bagels and even better muffins more than make up for it. The bagels are fresh and satisfying, but it's the muffins that steal the show with their moist texture and irresistible flavors. So, if you're willing to wait a bit for quality food, Bagelheads is definitely worth a visit.


Nearby Locations

Loading...

(850) 444-9661

916 E Gregory St, Pensacola, FL 32502