Anytime Arepa

Absolutely delicious wheat-free arepas - vegan, vegetarian, or meat, with a variety of sauces. For sides you can get beans or platanos. Inside the popular Third Street Market Hall with skyway to parking ramp. Vegetarian options: Beans, avocado, platanos (plantains). Dietary restrictions: Arepas are corn-based and wheat-free.

Incredible. This is the single best hand held food in Milwaukee. So much flavor. Fresh corn shell, delicious meat, vibrant salsas. Can't recommend enough. Definitely go for the feta cheese!

We had the empanadas and they were fantastic! We tried one of each and they were all delicious. The garlic sauce and the avocado sauce were great too. We will definitely be back.

I have eaten here at least 120 times since first having your food at generic electric pre-Covid. I have always had an unforgettable experience at anytime arepa, the definition of salt fat acid heat and am a big fan of the owners. I always appreciate the simple delicious balance of chew fat heat and salt. Made with love and extremely unique Best meal on a good day up there with Madison’s best empanada cart. Venzulan food done right for both trucks. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend this cart/ business family and friends. Although.. Today I had a cold lifeless arepa with unmelted cheese big hunks of cheese I would have the cheese to be held see above/ below experiences. Usually 5 star service food and vibes Today 1/5. A sad travesty to a meal that has me typically has me walking away memorized and wanting another later. I couldn’t believe what I was eating compared to usual experience. Arepa shell was barely warm Still perfect crunch. Unappetizing so so (medicore) cold beef/ chicken/ porkk when usually your carne is soo tender and delicious it is easy top five of any food cart I have visited nation wide and I have visited hundreds, with not enough aloli of any of the sandwiches (arepas). The online ordering system was not easy to use and left much to desired. Worst experience and I have eaten at least 120 arepas since precovid and I drove 2 hours to eat at your cart because it was always been truly unforgettable and had the perfect crunch and been so delicious I have had dreams about it and created a few worthwhile arepas at home. If this is the experience moving forward.. I won’t go a minute out of my way. This truck/ business usually leaves me in awe and inspired today the most forgetful meal I have this month. I walked feeling dissatisfied and much to be desired. Was unable to upgrade my arepas due to online ordering and was the only was the only party standing near the cart. Didn’t bother sharing my experience with the truck today due to all these good experiences. After a decade in the service industry these days happen but thought I should write about it. Would be open to try you guys again but my experience today was forgetful and unworthy invited a few friends for a birthday lunch and hardly recognized my arepa today Smh :/ friends who have had similar experiences said the same thing. I will be back but truly disappointed in my experience today vs the other experiences here. Feel free to verify purchase Much love and I’ll be back and have no doubts it was an off day. Beef plantain spicy aloli is the way. I guess next time I’ll go to caracas empanadas and get a hot worthy meal. save my save time money and energy, no affiliations with empanada cart, a long time customer who had a horrible experience. It’s right down the street (Caracas empanada) but this cart on a perfect day is absolute bliss truly. Will try again

Great place for a quick bite. It takes a bit of time (15 minutes) so you'll wait but that is because it is made fresh. I got the pork arepas with the garlic sauce. Perfect price and a great meal. I will certainly come back!

The chicken arepas are just fantastic! Those I've ordered with have also loved the pork. (Have only ordered through doordash so not familiar with the service or atmosphere but I'm sure just as great as the food)

I’ve been eating arepas from Anytime Arepa for 4-5 years now and they’re always delish and top-notch, no matter which location I visit- yum!