All Too Well Armitage

Amazing amazing sandwiches!!! I’ve been here twice now, and it’s been worth the walk both times. 10/10

I can’t eat pork and they wouldn’t make the sandwich I wanted without prosciutto. They do not care about allergies or intolerances. Response to the owner: The owner responded, claiming I am the only one star they’ve received. That is not true. I can see that somebody else had the same issue as me, in which the owner responded and claimed, similar to in this post, that that they “ will modify for allergies or intolerances.” This is clearly a lie as can be seen from my experience. I nicely informed about my dietary restriction regarding pork and was declined. Claiming it to be a miscommunication seems unlikely based on the experience of others… Moreover, the owner’s comment about Subway doesn’t really quite apply…I was merely asking to not put a certain meat on the sandwich. I wasn’t asking for a different ingredient, extra of the other meat, or anything else. If the sandwiches are made fresh, it shouldn’t be hard to NOT put a meat on the bread. So bizarre to say no to that. I worked at a sandwich shop myself for a summer and have never seen a request like that declined. Also, 50% of the sandwiches have pork, not just two.

Wow!!! We initially came for Evette’s (one of our faves) and saw the sister restaurant next door so decided to try this place out instead and we were not disappointed! After much deliberation (everything sounded SO good), we ordered the T & Bree and Tatanka. We were really impressed with the flavors! Highly recommend stopping by, we will definitely come again!

Got the vegetarian sandwich — so filling! So good! Fresh ingredients and welcoming atmosphere :) Great for a summer picnic

Just an awesome sandwich. Couldn’t fault it

This place has excellent sandwhich of the month rotations. Currently visiting and tried the OH Yeah for November. 10/10

Got my first sandwich from here this weekend. It was delicious! The bread was so fresh and their sauces were amazing. I got the tatanka. It was a sweeter buff chick sandwich but very flavorful

This is an inconspicuous little spot on Armitage, but houses some of the best sandwiches and soup I’ve had since moving to Chicago in 2014! Small but cozy atmosphere, friendly and fast service, and I found the prices incredibly fair for both the quality and size of the sandwiches. This place really should be more well-known! I highly recommend giving this lovely spot a try!