Agostinos Pizza

The place is closed down.

I ordered a small chicken, banana peppers, and spinach pizza! The small was the right amount for me and, it was filling. The pizza was delicious, along with the service! The customer service was terrific, and the owner was beneficial and friendly. Agostino’s is the new pizza spot to go!

Great deal and friendy service!

This is hands down the best pizza I’ve ever had. Amazing customer service, I highly recommend.

Loved the service and food very quality and yummy in my tummy

UPDATE Thank you, Agostino's, so much for reaching out to rectify! I am updating my review to give 5 stars! Our order was refunded, and we were given an order of cheese bread. Very cheesy, fantastic cheese bread! This is a business owner who cares about his product and ensuring our experience was turned around. We will absolutely be back. An unfortunate experience under new ownership. We spent over $70 for 3 burned pizzas and 2 orders of not so cheesy cheese bread. It was very disappointing that our food was not remade when they realized it was very overcooked and considering the amount we spent. A very disappointing experience.

I recently moved to the west side of Indianapolis and was trying to find good spots to eat. I was recommended by a friend to try out this black owned pizza restaurant and haven’t stopped going since! Very enjoyable food and the sicilian pizza is amazing.

This dude knows how to make a pizza !! Delicious !!

I ordered my pizza over the phone to pick up in store. When I arrived, I noticed a sign for a special, similar to what I ordered, but a larger size pizza for $4 less than my total. I asked the guy working why he didn’t tell me about the special. He said he’s supposed to get me to spend more money. I think it was a joke, and he said he would give me a discount next time, but I won’t be back. I used to order from there pretty regularly. They don’t appear to be a small business that can afford to lose customers to poor customer service, but Magoo’s is nearby and I’ll holler at them next time instead. Also, they changed their crust and it’s just ok. It was better before.

This pizza was so good they have Beef Pepperoni. Young man by the name of JoJo was fantastic and brought my order out to my jeep. Great Pizza. Great Sevice! I'll be back. Thank you JoJo!