Afters Ice Cream

Omg I can’t even begin to describe how fire this ice cream is upon discovering Afters, my go-to was Handels. Needless to say, they don’t even begin to compare to eachother. I’m a New York native and felt as if I instantly tasted heaven when I had my first scoop hahaha. I’m glad I’m living out here now or else I would have to protest for a NYC location! I’ve been craving it non stop I ordered delivery which was super convenient. Arrived frozen still, and was super tasty. I can’t wait to try other flavors moving forward!

My son loves this. However, I prefer traditional like Haagen Dazs. Everyone is different, so go have a taste. They are very nice, and will gladly give you tastes of different ice cream flavors.

Delicious! I've only been here a couple times but I've been satisfied every time. I don't get the donut ice cream sandwich thing but I have heard nothing but fantastic things about it. The ice cream I get is delicious, good portions, decent prices. No complaints here!

So good! Sugar coma, worth it!

We went at 10:30pm (30 min before closing). They said they “just ran out of sample spoons to use” when we asked to try a flavor of ice cream (even though we later found them at the front when we paid??). Then they claimed they just ran out of milky buns even though we could clearly see one of them putting them away. It was very much giving off vibes that they just didn’t want to work or were trying to clean early and not offer everything because they would have to clean. It was very off putting and honestly made me want to walk out but we got our ice cream and left. Probably not coming back here.

Awesome staff, the best Ice cream !!

They make great ice cream here, both texturally and flavorful. Grabbed a scoop of the cookie monster and was not disappointed.

We enjoyed our donut ice cream sandwiches!